Producer and script writing

Universal Studios began planning its remake of The House of the Seven Gables probably in early 1939. Pre-production for the film was secretive, as the studio feared that other companies with more financial resources might rush a House of Seven Gables into production before Universal could finish its version.^[5] The studio wanted the picture to be a low-budget B film, which would be released as a double feature with another B film.^[6] It was budgeted at a low $152,625 ($3,210,967 in 2022 dollars),^[6] but was still considered one of Universal's "prestige" horror films.^{[7][lower-alpha 1]}

Screenwriter Lester Cole says it was unclear why Universal chose to make the film, although it may have been because the book was in the public domain.^{[9][lower-alpha 2]} Film historian Don G. Smith, however, argues for an economic reason: Horror films were popular again. A national outcry against the gruesomeness of the 1935 film The Raven had convinced Universal Studios executives to place a ban on the production of horror films at the studio. But a New York City movie theater ran a triple-bill of Dracula, Frankenstein, and Son of Kong in 1938, and ticket sales were so strong that the theater ran the films 21 hours a day. Universal swiftly lifted its ban, and began production on a series of horror pictures: Son of Frankenstein, Sherlock Holmes and the House of Fear (aka The House of Fear), Black Friday, The Invisible Man Returns, The Mummy's Hand, The Invisible Woman, and The House of the Seven Gables.^[10]

Universal announced it would begin work on The House of the Seven Gables on October 10, 1939.^[11] The studio assigned one of its B-picture producers, Burt Kelly, to oversee the production.^[9] Kelly had an extensive background in theater, and had held a number of associate producer and producer positions at various studios.^[12] Universal also assigned one of its young staff writers, Harold Greene, to produce a treatment of the novel.^[9] Kelly had his choice of whom to hire as screenwriter, however, and he chose Lester Cole.^[9] Kelly had worked with Cole on a number of films, and film historian Bob Herzberg suggests that Kelly held progressive views which were shared by Cole (who openly held communist political views).^[13] Kelly, who Cole felt had "a real feeling for film and decent human instincts",^[14] was also a loyal friend of Cole's.^[9] Universal Studios initially balked at Kelly's decision because Cole's salary was $600 a week ($12,623 in 2022 dollars), but Kelly insisted and the studio gave in.^[9]

The lengthy novel by Nathaniel Hawthorne needed extensive cutting to turn it into a filmable script. Cole substantially cut much of the beginning of the novel, and altered a good deal of the plot—remaining faithful to the spirit of the novel if not its actual narrative.^[15] But Cole did more than adapt the novel. He purposefully injected extensive left-wing political views into the script. He turned the character of Matthew Maule/"Holgrave" into an abolitionist, and depicted capitalists like Jaffrey Pyncheon and Arnold Foster as illegal slave-traders.^[16][17] He also greatly sharpened Hawthorne's critique of materialism, and depicted the punishment for greed coming not from God (as Hawthorne did) but from moral and freedom-loving people.^[17] Film historian Lawrence Raw has argued that Cole, and to a lesser extent Greene, also wanted the story to attack authoritarianism. Cole in particular was deeply aware of the wave of fascism and dictatorship sweeping across Europe in the 1930s, and Raw argues that Cole transformed the film into a "propaganda piece" in which Jaffrey Pyncheon was a metaphor for governmental tyranny.^[6] Film historian and literary critic Thomas S. Hischak has argued that the final script ended up less about the novel and more about "variations on a theme by Hawthorne".^[18]

Production and casting

The film's low budget meant only modest production values.^[18] Nevertheless, production designer Jack Otterson went to Salem, Massachusetts, to take photographs and measurements of the Turner-Ingersoll Mansion (the inspiration for the House of the Seven Gables in Hawthorne's novel). A facade of the House of the Seven Gables was constructed on the Colonial Street backlot at Universal Studios^[19] (it remained standing into the 21st century).^[20] Interiors took up three soundstages at Universal Studios, with the primary sets representing the Seven Gables living room, lower hallway, and upper hallway.^[19] Props included more than 500 pieces of authentic early American tableware, kitchen pots, and kitchen utensils.^[19] Jack Pierce, makeup artist famous for his work in Universal's horror movies of the 1930s, came up with the makeup design for the lead performers (who age two decades or more during the course of the picture).^[21]

Universal Studios tested Margaret Lindsay for the role of Hepzibah Pyncheon on December 27, 1939.^{[22][lower-alpha 3]} Robert Cummings was originally cast as Clifford Pyncheon about December 28,^[24] but he fell ill the following day and was forced to leave the production.^{[21][25][26][lower-alpha 4]} Price was cast most likely because he had forged a good working relationship with Kelly and May in October 1939^[28] while working on The Invisible Man Returns.^[29][30] The studio announced Price's and Lindsay's casting, along with those of Nan Grey and George Sanders, on December 29. Studio publicists noted that the role of Matthew Maule remained unfilled.^[25][31]

The Los Angeles Times reported that principal photography was to have begun about December 24,^[32] but cameras did not begin rolling until December 29, 1939.^[33] The production shut down the same day due to casting problems and set construction delays.^[5] One of the problems was the height of the lead actors: Studio carpenters made the set for the average actor's height of 5 feet 9 inches (175 cm), but Price (6 feet 4 inches (193 cm)) and Sanders (6 feet 2 inches (188 cm)) were too tall. Doorway lintels and ceilings were quickly raised.^[28] Shooting resumed on January 3.^[5] The production was already three days behind schedule on January 5 due to problems with the period costumes, lighting, and the time-consuming aging makeup,^[5] and rain had delayed exterior shooting at the Seven Gables House.^[5]

Additional casting decisions were announced on January 4. Alan Napier, who had forged a deep friendship with Joe May on The Invisible Man Returns as well, was cast as the postman, Fuller.^[34][35] Dick Foran was cast as Matthew Maule and Gilbert Emery as Gerald Pyncheon that same day.^[35] Hiring for the major roles was not resolved until January 12, 1940, when the studio announced the casting of Cecil Kellaway and Charles Trowbridge.^[36] The following day, Universal announced that a song, "The Color of Your Eyes" (music and lyrics by Ralph Freed and Frank Skinner), had been added to the picture, and would be sung by Vincent Price.^[37] Additional delays occurred when airplanes flying over the set disrupted more exterior filming in mid January.^[5] Universal now began to put pressure on director Joe May to speed up the production.^[5] May did so, and by January 24 Trowbridge had finished all his scenes and had moved on to his next picture. The same day, Miles Mander was cast in the role of Arnold Foster.^[38] By working into the night (ten times between January 12 and the end of principal photography, the production did not break until 10 o'clock in the evening) the production was able to end in late January^[33] after 23 days of shooting (just two days over budget).^[5]

The film's final cost was $161,625.^[5][6]

Directing and acting

Joe May was hired as director because he'd helmed a series of Universal horror films in 1939, all of which had done well at the box office.^[7] May's background significantly influenced the film. He had fled his native Austria in 1934 due to the rise of Austrofascism,^[7] and became a contract director at Universal.^[39] May saw The House of the Seven Gables as a metaphor for opposing fascism and celebrating freedom of thought.^[40] But his background influenced the film in other ways, too. Alan Napier^[41] and Vincent Price^[28] both said that May had a heavy German accent, and had difficulty making himself understood in English.^[21] This hampered May's ability to direct his actors, and the studio ordered screenwriter Lester Cole to act as dialogue director.^[21]

Coming out of the German and Austrian film tradition, May was well versed in German Expressionism, and he introduced visual elements of this genre to the film. In one example, when Hepzibah descends the staircase, she casts a stark shadow against the wall. This is a visual doppelgänger, indicating that the character has two aspects which will be revealed in the film (the happy, youthful girl and the bitter, repressed spinster). May also used mise-en-scène, such as window panes or shadows, to show that the characters are trapped by Seven Gables or by circumstance.^[21]

George Sanders, a notoriously quick-witted individual with a cruel streak,^[42] did not get along with director Joe May, and Sanders ridiculed him openly.^[30] Alan Napier also said he had a poor on-set relationship with Sanders, who vociferously disliked Napier's good friend Anne Froelick.^[41] Film historians Tom Weaver, Michael Brunas, and John Brunas alleged that Price and Sanders also feuded on the set.^[42] But Price himself denied that he had a poor relationship with Sanders. Price later wrote that Sanders was "a dear and wonderful man. I knew him really intimately, and was very, very fond of him. He only pretended to be a dreadful man".^[30]

Premieres

The House of the Seven Gables premiered in Chicago, Illinois, on February 29, 1940,^[43] along with Black Friday. Vincent Price and Bela Lugosi, stars of the respective films, were in attendance.^{[5][lower-alpha 5]} The film went into general release on April 12, 1940,^[33] the same day it made its New York City premiere.^[44]

Reception

The film was released to generally good reviews in the press.^[16] Lester Cole felt the script was one of the best he ever wrote,^[17] and later said that few reviewers made note of the extensive plot revisions he had made.^[45] Price and Sanders, both relative unknowns at the time, delivered good performances which boosted their careers significantly.^[18][46] Film historian Thomas S. Hischak said Margaret Lindsay was also very good as Hepzibah Pyncheon.^[18] Composer Frank Skinner received a nomination for the Academy Award for Best Original Score.^[47]

The film's reputation suffered in the 1950s. During the Second Red Scare of 1947 to 1957, Universal Studio executives criticized the film because, they said, Kelly and Cole had injected radical politics into the script and the directing.^[16]

Modern critics give mixed reviews to the picture. Vincent Price biographer Denis Meikle has called the film "overly sentimental", and criticized the aging make-up as not very good.^[48] He thought the movie was suspenseful, but also typical of the "mild" and "inoffensive" period pictures of the era.^[26]