Main cast

• Hugh O'Brian as Wyatt Earp (229 episodes)
• Morgan Woodward as "Shotgun" Gibbs (81 episodes)
• Ray Kellogg as Deputy Ollie (13 episodes)
• William Tannen as Deputy Hal Norton (56 episodes)
• Douglas Fowley/Myron Healey as John H. "Doc" Holliday (49 episodes/10 episodes)
• Mason Alan Dinehart as Bat Masterson (34 episodes)
• Fred Coby as Pony Deal (5 episodes)
• Damian O'Flynn as Judge Tobin/Dr. Goodfellow (68 episodes)
• Ray Boyle as Morgan Earp (15 episodes)
• John Anderson/Ross Elliott as Virgil Earp (5 episodes/4 episodes)
• Bill Cassady as Dr. McCarty (11 episodes)

Recurring cast

• Jimmy Noel as Townsman (144 episodes)
• Ethan Laidlaw as Townsman (138 episodes)
• Bill Coontz as Townsman (99 episodes)
• Chet Brandenburg as Townsman (79 episodes)
• Buddy Roosevelt as Townsman (65 episodes)
• Kermit Maynard as Townsman (48 episodes)
• Frank Mills as Townsman (36 episodes)
• Archie Butler as Townsman (32 episodes)
• Milan Smith as Townsman (16 episodes)
• Albert Cavens as Townsman (16 episodes)
• Tex Palmer as Townsman (15 episodes)
• Herman Hack as Townsman (10 episodes)
• Chick Hannan as Townsman (6 episodes)
• Alex Sharp as Townsman (4 episodes)
• Paul Brinegar/Ralph Sanford as James H. "Dog" Kelley (34 episodes/21 episodes)
• Rico Alaniz as Mr. Cousin (19 episodes)
• Rodd Redwing as Mr. Brother (8 episodes)
• James Seay as Judge Wells Spicer (25 episodes)
• Don Haggerty as Marsh Murdock (21 episodes)
• Trevor Bardette as Newman Haynes Clanton (21 episodes)
• John Milford/Rayford Barnes as Ike Clanton (8 episodes)
• Carol Thurston as Emma Clanton (7 episodes)
• William Phipps as Curly Bill Brocius (16 episodes)
• Randy Stuart as Nellie Cashman (12 episodes)
• Carol Montgomery Stone/Collette Lyons as "Big Nose Kate" (10 episodes/4 episodes)
• Steve Brodie/Lash La Rue as Sheriff Johnny Behan, member of the Ten Percent Ring (9 episodes/8 episodes)
• Gregg Palmer as Tom McLowery (4 episodes)
• Margaret Hayes as Dora Hand (3 episodes)
• Denver Pyle/Walter Coy as Ben Thompson (8 episodes/1 episode)
• Bob Steele as Deputy Sam (4 episodes)
• Donald Murphy/Norman Alden as Johnny Ringo/Johnny Ringgold (6 episodes)
• William Mims as Dameron (6 episodes)
• Walter Maslow as Dick Averill/Blackie Saunders (5 episodes)
• Barney Phillips as Lou Rickabaugh (3 episodes)
• Norman Leavitt as Mr. Phillips (2 episodes)

Guest cast

On September 25, 1956, Myron Healey played a drunken gunfighter Clay Allison, who comes into Dodge City to confront the Earp legend. In the story line, Pete Albright, a storeowner played by Charles Fredricks, tries to hire Allison to gun down Earp because the marshal is fighting crime in the town and costing merchants business in the process. Allison makes a point of not taking money, but is willing to challenge Earp until he is overcome by his own drunkenness. Mike Ragan played Clay Allison in a 1957 episode, "The Time for All Good Men".

Development

The series was produced by Desilu Productions and filmed at the Desilu-Cahuenga Studio. Sponsors included General Mills, Procter & Gamble, and Parker Pen Company. Off-camera the Ken Darby singers, a choral group, sang the theme song and hummed the background music. The theme song "The Legend of Wyatt Earp" was composed by Harry Warren. Incidental music was composed by Herman Stein.

Casting

O'Brian was chosen for the role in part because of his physical resemblance to early photographs of Wyatt Earp.

Douglas Fowley and Myron Healey were cast 49 and 10 times, respectively, as Earp's close friend John H. "Doc" Holliday.^[6]

Mason Alan Dinehart, or Alan Dinehart, III, son of film stars Alan Dinehart and Mozelle Britton, was cast in 34 episodes between 1955 and 1959 as Bat Masterson, a role filled on the NBC series of the same name by the late Gene Barry. Dinehart played Masterson from the ages of 19 to 23.^[7]

Many episodes show Douglas Fowley as playing the part of Doc Fabrique when he actually is not in the episodes. O'Flynn was left off the credits most of the time.

Bob Steele played Wyatt's deputy, Sam, in four episodes in 1955 during the Wichita period.

Use of Buntline Special

In the show, O'Brian carried a Buntline Special, a pistol with a 12-inch barrel, which triggered a mild toy craze at the time the series was originally broadcast. No credible evidence has been found that Wyatt Earp ever owned such a gun. The myth of Earp carrying a Buntline Special was created in Stuart N. Lake's best-selling 1931 biography Wyatt Earp: Frontier Marshal, later admitted by the author to be highly fictionalized.^[8]

Historical Accuracy

In contrast to the always-ethical character portrayed in the series, the real-life Wyatt Earp was at various times on either side of the law, having been accused of horse stealing, criminal assault, and involvement with fight-fixing, gambling, prostitution, and murders.^[9][10]

The real Wyatt Earp was elected town constable of Lamar, Missouri, in 1870,^[9] and became a Wichita, Kansas policeman in 1873.^[9] He was appointed as an assistant marshal in Dodge City around May 1876, spent the winter of 1876–77 in Deadwood, Dakota Territory,^[11]: 31 and rejoined the Dodge City police force as an assistant marshal in spring 1877. He resigned his position in September 1879.^[12]

Earp is depicted as the town marshal in Tombstone, although his brother Virgil Earp was Deputy U.S. Marshal and Tombstone City Marshal.^[13]: 28 As city marshal, Virgil made the decision to enforce a city ordinance prohibiting carrying weapons in town and to disarm the outlaw cowboys that led to the Gunfight at the O.K. Corral. Wyatt was only a temporary assistant marshal to his brother.^[14]

Ratings

The Life and Legend of Wyatt Earp finished number 18 in the Nielsen ratings for the 1956–1957 season,^[19] number six in 1957–1958,^[20] number 10 in 1958–1959,^[21] and number 20 in 1959–1960.^[22]

Awards

The series received two Emmy nominations in 1957. Hugh O'Brian was nominated for Best Continuing Performance by an Actor,^[23] and Dan Ullman earned a nomination for Best Teleplay Writing - Half Hour or Less.^[24]