 | |||||||||||||||||||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||
| Turnout | 18,440 (46.15%) | ||||||||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| |||||||||||||||||||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||
.jpg.webp)
The 1971 Lower Hutt mayoral election was part of the New Zealand local elections held that same year. The elections were held for the role of Mayor of Lower Hutt plus other local government positions including fifteen city councillors, also elected triennially. The polling was conducted using the standard first-past-the-post electoral method.
Background
1970 mid-term election
Mayor Percy Dowse died mid-term on 9 December 1970. Rather than hold a by-election the city council members decided to elect a councillor to finish the remainder of the term until the scheduled election 10 months later.[1] The council special meeting was held on 21 December. Councillor Chen Werry was nominated by Walter Gordon Bugden and seconded by Jessie Donald but he unexpectedly declined nomination. Cyril Phelps then nominated John Kennedy-Good which was seconded by Harold Meachen and finally the deputy mayor Dave Hadley was nominated by Ted Holdaway and seconded by Don Lee. A vote was held among the councillors by a show of hands. A visible split was seen with Citizens' Association councillors, splitting support between Hadley and Kennedy-Good, with Labour councillors (who were the minority on the council) all voting for Kennedy-Good who won nine votes to six.[2]
A list of each Councillors vote:
| Councillor | Mayoral Vote | |
|---|---|---|
| Max Borra | Hadley | |
| Walter Gordon Bugden | Kennedy-Good | |
| Sam Chesney | Kennedy-Good | |
| Jessie Donald | Kennedy-Good | |
| Stan Frost | Hadley | |
| Ted Gibbs | Kennedy-Good | |
| Dave Hadley | Hadley | |
| Ted Holdaway | Hadley | |
| John Kennedy-Good | Kennedy-Good | |
| Don Lee | Hadley | |
| Harold Meachen | Kennedy-Good | |
| Kitty Mildenhall | Kennedy-Good | |
| Cyril Phelps | Kennedy-Good | |
| Jim Ross | Hadley | |
| Chen Werry | Kennedy-Good | |
October 1971 election
Even after councillors elected Kennedy-Good as Dowse's successor the Citizens' Association, who had a majority on the council, did not select Kennedy-Good for the 1971 election. Instead they chose the deputy mayor (and 1968 candidate) Dave Hadley instead. As a result Kennedy-Good formed his own "combined" electoral ticket, consisting of candidates who were previously Citizens' and Labour affiliated, with which to contest the election. Thinking that the Labour Party was not intending to put up a ticket of their own, four Labour councillors joined the combined team. Labour did eventually decide to run its own ticket and party policy dictated that members could not stand for election against official party candidates resulting them having their Labour membership suspended.[1]
In an evenly divided poll Kennedy-Good narrowly edged out former Labour councillor John Seddon to win the mayoralty.[3] The city council was split three ways, with Labour winning a plurality of seats. Labour and Citizens' councillors made a deal to elect their own members to committee chairs and voted Seddon as deputy mayor, sidelining the Combined Team.[1]
At the election both a father and son were elected to the council. Chen Werry was re-elected to the council on the combined ticket while his son, Dick Werry, won a seat on the Labour ticket.[4] It also saw the election of the city's first ever Indian councillor, Govind Bhula, a civil engineer originally from Bombay.[5]
Mayoral results
| Party | Candidate | Votes | % | ±% | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Combined Team | John Kennedy-Good | 6,854 | 37.16 | ||
| Labour | John Seddon | 6,337 | 34.36 | ||
| Citizens' | Dave Hadley | 4,630 | 25.10 | -22.03 | |
| Independent | Nick Ursin | 484 | 2.62 | ||
| Informal votes | 135 | 0.73 | -0.64 | ||
| Majority | 517 | 2.80 | |||
| Turnout | 18,440 | 46.15 | +3.14 | ||
Councillor results
| Party | Candidate | Votes | % | ±% | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Labour | John Seddon | 8,610 | 46.69 | ||
| Labour | Kitty Mildenhall | 8,146 | 44.17 | -4.53 | |
| Citizens' | Don Lee | 7,482 | 40.57 | -13.04 | |
| Combined Team | Chen Werry | 7,225 | 39.18 | -16.82 | |
| Citizens' | Harold Turbott | 7,133 | 38.68 | ||
| Combined Team | Sam Chesney | 7,018 | 38.05 | -11.64 | |
| Labour | Lawrie Woodley | 6,995 | 37.93 | ||
| Citizens' | Andrew Gordon Ash | 6,860 | 37.20 | ||
| Combined Team | Jessie Donald | 6,737 | 36.53 | -11.23 | |
| Labour | Govind Bhula | 6,548 | 35.50 | ||
| Labour | Ernie Barry | 6,494 | 35.21 | ||
| Combined Team | Stan Ramsom | 6,344 | 34.40 | ||
| Labour | Dick Werry | 6,258 | 33.93 | ||
| Combined Team | Ted Gibbs | 6,130 | 33.24 | -13.57 | |
| Labour | Les Duckworth | 6,030 | 32.70 | ||
| Citizens' | Francis John Cameron | 5,974 | 32.39 | ||
| Labour | David Brian Carrad | 5,966 | 32.35 | -10.08 | |
| Combined Team | Cyril Phelps | 5,934 | 32.18 | -15.13 | |
| Combined Team | Gerald Bond | 5,879 | 31.88 | ||
| Citizens' | Max Borra | 5,693 | 30.87 | -14.93 | |
| Labour | Jack Ward | 5,612 | 30.43 | ||
| Labour | Bert Sutherland | 5,597 | 30.35 | -11.46 | |
| Labour | Laurie Sutton | 5,596 | 30.34 | ||
| Combined Team | Jim Ross | 5,496 | 29.80 | -15.75 | |
| Labour | Peter Gordon Palmer | 5,458 | 29.59 | ||
| Labour | Laurence Phillip Lowe | 5,391 | 29.23 | ||
| Combined Team | Glen Evans | 5,388 | 29.21 | ||
| Citizens' | Stan Frost | 5,354 | 29.03 | -21.48 | |
| Labour | Alick Shaw | 5,221 | 28.31 | ||
| Combined Team | David Kincaid | 4,807 | 26.06 | ||
| Combined Team | Vince Fitzgibbon | 4,654 | 25.23 | ||
| Combined Team | Eric Pearce | 4,564 | 24.75 | ||
| Citizens' | David James Smith | 4,526 | 24.54 | ||
| Combined Team | Keith Thomas | 4,427 | 24.00 | ||
| Citizens' | Parone Matiu | 4,405 | 23.88 | ||
| Labour | Graeme Smith | 4,354 | 23.61 | ||
| Citizens' | Sadie Williams | 4,254 | 23.06 | ||
| Combined Team | Bill Lambert | 4,197 | 22.76 | ||
| Combined Team | Ray Partridge | 4,183 | 22.68 | ||
| Citizens' | George Ian Hooper | 3,872 | 20.99 | ||
| Citizens' | Raymond Joseph McLaughlin | 3,823 | 20.73 | ||
| Citizens' | Joseph David Peters | 3,717 | 20.15 | ||
| Citizens' | Robert McMurray | 3,665 | 19.87 | ||
| Citizens' | Charles Edward Maxted | 3,624 | 19.65 | ||
| Citizens' | Andrew George Gathergood | 3,540 | 19.19 | -19.85 | |
| Independent | Nick Ursin | 2,400 | 13.01 | -3.68 | |
| Independent | Anthony Francis Foot | 1,780 | 9.65 | ||
Notes
- 1 2 3 McGill 1991, p. 189.
- ↑ "Dentist Mr Kennedy-Good Elected 14th Mayor of Lower Hutt on 9-6 Vote in Council". The Evening Post. 22 December 1970. p. 3.
- ↑ "Mr Kennedy-Good Just Retains Mayoralty in Face of Labour Bid". The Evening Post. 11 October 1971. p. 1.
- ↑ "Son Joins Father on L Hutt Council". The Evening Post. 11 October 1971. p. 2.
- ↑ "LH Elects Indian Councillor". The Evening Post. 11 October 1971. p. 2.
- ↑ "City of Lower Hutt - Declaration of Result of Election - Election of Mayor". The Evening Post. 16 October 1971. p. 44.
- ↑ "City of Lower Hutt - Declaration of Result of Election - Election of Councillors". The Evening Post. 16 October 1971. p. 44.
References
- McGill, David (1991). Lower Hutt – The First Garden City. Petone, New Zealand: Lower Hutt City Council. ISBN 1-86956-003-5.