A bidirectional text contains two text directionalities, right-to-left (RTL) and left-to-right (LTR). It generally involves text containing different types of alphabets, but may also refer to boustrophedon, which is changing text direction in each row.
Many computer programs fail to display bidirectional text correctly. For example, this page is mostly LTR English script, and here is the RTL Hebrew name Sarah: שרה, spelled sin (ש) on the right, resh (ר) in the middle, and heh (ה) on the left.
Some so-called right-to-left scripts such as the Persian script and Arabic are mostly, but not exclusively, right-to-left—mathematical expressions, numeric dates and numbers bearing units are embedded from left to right. That also happens if text from a left-to-right language such as English is embedded in them; or vice versa, if Arabic is embedded in a left-to-right script such as English.
Bidirectional script support
Bidirectional script support is the capability of a computer system to correctly display bidirectional text. The term is often shortened to "BiDi" or "bidi".
Early computer installations were designed only to support a single writing system, typically for left-to-right scripts based on the Latin alphabet only. Adding new character sets and character encodings enabled a number of other left-to-right scripts to be supported, but did not easily support right-to-left scripts such as Arabic or Hebrew, and mixing the two was not practical. Right-to-left scripts were introduced through encodings like ISO/IEC 8859-6 and ISO/IEC 8859-8, storing the letters (usually) in writing and reading order. It is possible to simply flip the left-to-right display order to a right-to-left display order, but doing this sacrifices the ability to correctly display left-to-right scripts. With bidirectional script support, it is possible to mix characters from different scripts on the same page, regardless of writing direction.
In particular, the Unicode standard provides foundations for complete BiDi support, with detailed rules as to how mixtures of left-to-right and right-to-left scripts are to be encoded and displayed.
Unicode bidi support
The Unicode standard calls for characters to be ordered 'logically', i.e. in the sequence they are intended to be interpreted, as opposed to 'visually', the sequence they appear. This distinction is relevant for bidi support because at any bidi transition, the visual presentation ceases to be the 'logical' one. Thus, in order to offer bidi support, Unicode prescribes an algorithm for how to convert the logical sequence of characters into the correct visual presentation. For this purpose, the Unicode encoding standard divides all its characters into one of four types: 'strong', 'weak', 'neutral', and 'explicit formatting'.[1]
Strong characters
Strong characters are those with a definite direction. Examples of this type of character include most alphabetic characters, syllabic characters, Han ideographs, non-European or non-Arabic digits, and punctuation characters that are specific to only those scripts.
Weak characters
Weak characters are those with vague direction. Examples of this type of character include European digits, Eastern Arabic-Indic digits, arithmetic symbols, and currency symbols.
Neutral characters
Neutral characters have direction indeterminable without context. Examples include paragraph separators, tabs, and most other whitespace characters. Punctuation symbols that are common to many scripts, such as the colon, comma, full-stop, and the no-break-space also fall within this category.
Explicit formatting
Explicit formatting characters, also referred to as "directional formatting characters", are special Unicode sequences that direct the algorithm to modify its default behavior. These characters are subdivided into "marks", "embeddings", "isolates", and "overrides". Their effects continue until the occurrence of either a paragraph separator, or a "pop" character.
Marks
If a "weak" character is followed by another "weak" character, the algorithm will look at the first neighbouring "strong" character. Sometimes this leads to unintentional display errors. These errors are corrected or prevented with "pseudo-strong" characters. Such Unicode control characters are called marks. The mark (U+200E LEFT-TO-RIGHT MARK (LRM) or U+200F RIGHT-TO-LEFT MARK (RLM)) is to be inserted into a location to make an enclosed weak character inherit its writing direction.
For example, to correctly display the U+2122 ™ TRADE MARK SIGN for an English name brand (LTR) in an Arabic (RTL) passage, an LRM mark is inserted after the trademark symbol if the symbol is not followed by LTR text (e.g. "قرأ Wikipedia™ طوال اليوم."). If the LRM mark is not added, the weak character ™ will be neighbored by a strong LTR character and a strong RTL character. Hence, in an RTL context, it will be considered to be RTL, and displayed in an incorrect order (e.g. "قرأ Wikipedia™ طوال اليوم.").
Embeddings
The "embedding" directional formatting characters are the classical Unicode method of explicit formatting, and as of Unicode 6.3, are being discouraged in favor of "isolates". An "embedding" signals that a piece of text is to be treated as directionally distinct. The text within the scope of the embedding formatting characters is not independent of the surrounding text. Also, characters within an embedding can affect the ordering of characters outside. Unicode 6.3 recognized that directional embeddings usually have too strong an effect on their surroundings and are thus unnecessarily difficult to use.
Isolates
The "isolate" directional formatting characters signal that a piece of text is to be treated as directionally isolated from its surroundings. As of Unicode 6.3, these are the formatting characters that are being encouraged in new documents – once target platforms are known to support them. These formatting characters were introduced after it became apparent that directional embeddings usually have too strong an effect on their surroundings and are thus unnecessarily difficult to use. Unlike the legacy 'embedding' directional formatting characters, 'isolate' characters have no effect on the ordering of the text outside their scope. Isolates can be nested, and may be placed within embeddings and overrides.
Overrides
The "override" directional formatting characters allow for special cases, such as for part numbers (e.g. to force a part number made of mixed English, digits and Hebrew letters to be written from right to left), and are recommended to be avoided wherever possible. As is true of the other directional formatting characters, "overrides" can be nested one inside another, and in embeddings and isolates.
Pops
The "pop" directional formatting characters terminate the scope of the most recent "embedding", "override", or "isolate".
Runs
In the algorithm, each sequence of concatenated strong characters is called a "run". A "weak" character that is located between two "strong" characters with the same orientation will inherit their orientation. A "weak" character that is located between two "strong" characters with a different writing direction will inherit the main context's writing direction (in an LTR document the character will become LTR, in an RTL document, it will become RTL).
Table of possible BiDi character types
| Type[2] | Description | Strength | Directionality | General scope | Bidi_Control character[3] |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| L | Left-to-Right | Strong | L-to-R | Most alphabetic and syllabic characters, Chinese characters, non-European or non-Arabic digits, LRM character, ... | U+200E LEFT-TO-RIGHT MARK (LRM) |
| R | Right-to-Left | Strong | R-to-L | Adlam, Hebrew, Mandaic, Mende Kikakui, N'Ko, Samaritan, ancient scripts like Kharoshthi and Nabataean, RLM character, ... | U+200F RIGHT-TO-LEFT MARK (RLM) |
| AL | Arabic Letter | Strong | R-to-L | Arabic, Hanifi Rohingya, Sogdian, Syriac, and Thaana alphabets, and most punctuation specific to those scripts, ALM character, ... | U+061C ARABIC LETTER MARK (ALM) |
| EN | European Number | Weak | European digits, Eastern Arabic-Indic digits, Coptic epact numbers, ... | ||
| ES | European Separator | Weak | plus sign, minus sign, ... | ||
| ET | European Number Terminator | Weak | degree sign, currency symbols, ... | ||
| AN | Arabic Number | Weak | Arabic-Indic digits, Arabic decimal and thousands separators, Rumi digits, Hanifi Rohingya digits, ... | ||
| CS | Common Number Separator | Weak | colon, comma, full stop, no-break space, ... | ||
| NSM | Nonspacing Mark | Weak | Characters in General Categories Mark, nonspacing, and Mark, enclosing (Mn, Me) | ||
| BN | Boundary Neutral | Weak | Default ignorables, non-characters, control characters other than those explicitly given other types | ||
| B | Paragraph Separator | Neutral | paragraph separator, appropriate Newline Functions, higher-level protocol paragraph determination | ||
| S | Segment Separator | Neutral | Tabs | ||
| WS | Whitespace | Neutral | space, figure space, line separator, form feed, General Punctuation block spaces (smaller set than the Unicode whitespace list) | ||
| ON | Other Neutrals | Neutral | All other characters, including object replacement character | ||
| LRE | Left-to-Right Embedding | Explicit | L-to-R | LRE character only | U+202A LEFT-TO-RIGHT EMBEDDING (LRE) |
| LRO | Left-to-Right Override | Explicit | L-to-R | LRO character only | U+202D LEFT-TO-RIGHT OVERRIDE (LRO) |
| RLE | Right-to-Left Embedding | Explicit | R-to-L | RLE character only | U+202B RIGHT-TO-LEFT EMBEDDING (RLE) |
| RLO | Right-to-Left Override | Explicit | R-to-L | RLO character only | U+202E RIGHT-TO-LEFT OVERRIDE (RLO) |
| Pop Directional Format | Explicit | PDF character only | U+202C POP DIRECTIONAL FORMATTING (PDF) | ||
| LRI | Left-to-Right Isolate | Explicit | L-to-R | LRI character only | U+2066 LEFT-TO-RIGHT ISOLATE (LRI) |
| RLI | Right-to-Left Isolate | Explicit | R-to-L | RLI character only | U+2067 RIGHT-TO-LEFT ISOLATE (RLI) |
| FSI | First Strong Isolate | Explicit | FSI character only | U+2068 FIRST STRONG ISOLATE (FSI) | |
| PDI | Pop Directional Isolate | Explicit | PDI character only | U+2069 POP DIRECTIONAL ISOLATE (PDI) | |
Notes
| |||||
Security
Unicode bidirectional characters are used in the Trojan Source vulnerability.[2]
Visual Studio Code highlights BiDi control characters since version 1.62 released in October 2021.[3]
Visual Studio highlights BiDi control characters since version 17.0.3 released on December 14, 2021.[4]
Scripts using bidirectional text
Egyptian hieroglyphs
Egyptian hieroglyphs were written bidirectionally, where the signs that had a distinct "head" or "tail" faced the beginning of the line.
Chinese characters and other CJK scripts
Chinese characters can be written in either direction as well as vertically (top to bottom then right to left), especially in signs (such as plaques), but the orientation of the individual characters does not change. This can often be seen on tour buses in China, where the company name customarily runs from the front of the vehicle to its rear — that is, from right to left on the right side of the bus, and from left to right on the left side of the bus. English texts on the right side of the vehicle are also quite commonly written in reverse order. (See pictures of tour bus and post vehicle below.)
Likewise, other CJK scripts made up of the same square characters, such as the Japanese writing system and Korean writing system, can also be written in any direction, although horizontally left-to-right, top-to-bottom and vertically top-to-bottom right-to-left are the two most common forms.
The right side (text runs from right to left, including the English text)
The left side (text runs from left to right)
On the right side of this Hainan Airlines aircraft, the text runs from right to left (空航南海).
The left side of this Hainan Airlines aircraft, however, shows the text running from left to right (海南航空).
A photo that shows text on both sides of a China Post vehicle. On the right door, china post appears as tsop anihc.
Boustrophedon
Boustrophedon is a writing style found in ancient Greek inscriptions, in Old Sabaic (an Old South Arabian language) and in Hungarian runes. This method of writing alternates direction, and usually reverses the individual characters, on each successive line.
Moon type
Moon type is an embossed adaptation of the Latin alphabet invented as a tactile alphabet for the blind. Initially the text changed direction (but not character orientation) at the end of the lines. Special embossed lines connected the end of a line and the beginning of the next.[5] Around 1990, it changed to a left-to-right orientation.
See also
References
- ↑ "UAX #9: Unicode Bi-directional Algorithm". Unicode.org. 2018-05-09. Retrieved 2018-06-26.
- ↑ "Trojan Source Attacks". trojansource.codes. Retrieved 17 January 2022.
- ↑ "Visual Studio Code October 2021". code.visualstudio.com. Retrieved 11 November 2021.
- ↑ "Visual Studio 2022 version 17.0 Release Notes". docs.microsoft.com. Retrieved 17 January 2022.
- ↑ Moon Type for the Blind, Ramseyer Bible Collection, Kathryn A. Martin Library, University of Minnesota Duluth.
External links
- Unicode Standards Annex #9 The Bidirectional Algorithm
- W3C guidelines on authoring techniques for bi-directional text - includes examples and good explanations
- ICU International Components for Unicode contains an implementation of the bi-directional algorithm — along with other internationalization services
