Honeycomb housing is an urban planning model pertaining to residential subdivision design.
The defining hexagonal tessellation, or "honeycomb" pattern, consists of multiple housing clusters containing 5-16 houses and centered around a courtyard in a cul-de-sac arrangement at its smallest unit of organization. Multiple clusters are connected to each other to form larger cul-de-sac communities with up to 42 houses in total. These courtyard communities are in turn also connected to one another, making up a distinct neighborhood of up to 300 houses.[1]
The honeycomb concept was first introduced in Malaysia as an alternative to terrace houses and the predominantly rectilinear form of residential layouts.
It can also be described as a new form of cul-de-sac layout.
From Cul-de-sac to Honeycomb
Cul-de-sacs are popular: they are perceived as being safer, more exclusive and neighbourly. According to one study, between the ‘grid’, ‘loops’ and cul-de-sacs, the latter were the most popular.[2] These houses are used in Malaysia.[3]
Since houses are built around a small park with plentiful shady trees, this communal garden is easily accessible to all in the cul-de-sac, allowing it to act as a social focus that can encourage social interaction and neighborly spirit.[4][5]
The courtyard area is a "defensible space" as well, as it acts naturally to reduce crime in the sense that strangers are quickly spotted. The short winding roads put a stop to speeding traffic, and certain to dissuade snatch thieves on motorcycles - therefore becoming safe for children, pedestrians and cyclists.[6]
Apart from the social advantages, it is also claimed that compared to the terrace house layout, the honeycomb layout uses land efficiently and offers savings in the cost of infrastructure.[7]
The honeycomb Layout may be said to be inspired from the geometrical design of Islamic tiles and the structure of beehives. Introduced by Kuala Lumpur-based architect Mazlin Ghazali, it has received a patent in Australia [8]
Honeycomb Housing projects under construction
The honeycomb concept has been applied to a hillside development on 14 acres of land at Kampung Nong Chik the edge of Johor Bahru business district in a development which advertises a modern version of the traditional village or "kampong" lifestyle.[9]
Criticism
Being so new, many developers would worry about the difficulty of obtaining approvals from the local authorities and so hesitate to be the first to adopt the honeycomb concept.[10] Another problem is that the houses are not rectangular and the house design ends up with odd corners in the house.[11] Another criticism comes from followers ‘fengshui’, the ancient Chinese art of geomancy, who believe that in a cul-de-sac ‘the chi energy coming to a house placed at the end of a road is usually fast, so the energy is pernicious and non-beneficial. Instead of bringing good fortune, it brings misfortune’.[12]
Nowadays cul-de-sacs are often frowned upon in planning circles,[13] especially by supporters of the New Urbanism: However the Honeycomb housing concept - which allows relatively high density - does appear to overcome some of the concerns here.[14]
References
- ↑ Mazlin Ghazali, Michael J. Durack, Mohd Peter Davis (2005), "Tessellation Planning and Honeycomb Housing", Planning Malaysia, Journal of the Malaysian Institute of Planners Vol. 3 pp.71-98 retrieved 25 September 2010
- ↑ Eran Ben-Joseph (1995), "Livability and Safety of Suburban Street Patterns: a Comparative Study", Working Paper 641, Berkeley, CA: University of California
- ↑ Alter, Lloyd (7 April 2008). "Reinventing the Cul-de-Sac". treehugger.com. Archived from the original on 11 September 2011. Retrieved 26 November 2020.
- ↑ New Straits Times, Malaysia, Property Times 4 June 2005 issue, "Building like a bee", by G. Umakanthan, 4 June 2005 Retrieved 25 September 2010
- ↑ Habsah Hashim, "Harmonious Community Living in Urban Neighbourhoods: A Case of Central Shah Alam", 8th. International Asian Planning Schools Association Congress, September, 2005; p18 Retrieved 25 September 2010
- ↑ Nikmatul Adha Nordin & Wan Rafyah Wan Muhd Zin, "Incorporating Children in Neighbourhood Design and Planning", International Asian Planning Schools Association Congress, September, 2005; pp9 Retrieved 25 September 2010
- ↑ Mazlin Ghazali, Mohd Peter Davis (December 2005), "Affordable Honeycomb Housing", Architecture Malaysia: Journal of the Malaysian Institute of Architects Volume 17 Issue 6 pp.36-40
- ↑ IP Australia, "A method of subdividing a plot of land for housing and a housing subdivision so formed", retrieved 25 September 2010
- ↑ George Lam (2009), "HA: ideas and Concepts", Pace Publishing Limited, Hong Kong; pp 166-168
- ↑ Nikmatul Adha Nordin & Wan Rafyah Wan Muhd Zin, "Incorporating Children in Neighbourhood Design and Planning", International Asian Planning Schools Association Congress, September, 2005 Retrieved 25 September 2010
- ↑ The Edge, Malaysia, City & Country: "Good take-up for unsold stock", by Jacqui Chan, Monday, 26 October 2009 Archived 7 October 2011 at the Wayback Machine retrieved 25 September 2010
- ↑ World of Feng Shui website, "What To Do If You Live In A Cul-De-Sac", by Lillian Too retrieved 25 September 2010
- ↑ The Toronto Star, "End of the road for the cul-de-sac? Why planners and environmentalists are waging war on suburbia's lollipop developments" by Peter Gorrie, Sat 29 Mar 2008; retrieved 25 September 2010
- ↑ Treehugger.com website, Design and Architecture, "Reinventing the Cul-de-Sac", by Lloyd Alter,7 April 2008 retrieved 25 September 2010
Further reading
- Mohd Peter Davis, Nor Azian Nordin, Mazlin Ghazali (2006), "Thermal comfort Honeycomb Housing", Universiti Putra Malaysia ISBN 983-3455-38-7