Consul General

In 2006 Tamir was appointed Consul General of Israel to New England at the Consulate General of Israel in Boston, MA. He served in this position right after the Second Lebanon War, the IDF operation in the Gaza Strip, and during the time of the later Operation Cast Lead. During this time, disagreements between the Government of Israel and the Obama Administration have grown dramatically, regarding the freeze of the Peace process, and Israel's policy on settlements expansion. Tamir has worked tirelessly to explain the Israeli policy to the American public and to the Administration, although in many cases he thought that his government stance was wrong and was defeating the Israeli interest. He received vast praises from the Jewish community leaders,^[3] leading academia researchers who specialize in the Middle East,^[4] as well as top government officials. Among other activities, Tamir created good ties with US Congress members, and helped in advancing legislation in crucial issues relating to the security of Israel, such as the nuclear program of Iran.^[5]

Nadav Tamir with presidents Shimon Peres and Barack Obama in Israel, March 2013

The Critical Memo incident

Tamir became known to the public following a three-page memo, which he wrote for the eyes of Foreign Ministry officials only. In this letter, Tamir criticized the handling of the relations with the US administration. Later on, it appeared that this was just a pioneering letter, followed by other such documents written by Israeli ambassadors to leading western countries.^[6]

Tamir wrote the letter in the end of his third year as consul. He did this after he realized, as he said, of the negative atmosphere towards Israel in the Administration, which was the result of mistaken and un-diplomatic handling of the interactions between the governments. Tamir claimed that it was his duty, as official Israeli representative, to be the messenger of such phenomena which he thought were causing severe damage to Israel's foreign relations, so that the Israeli cabinet would be aware of some results of its policy and actions. He said that it was not his intention to criticize the policy itself of the Israeli government, but the way it was communicated.

Nadav Tamir with the President of the United States, Barack Obama

The letter was leaked (not by Tamir) and was made public on August 6, 2010, in Israel's Channel 10 Television. The publication stirred harsh criticism,^[7] and some called to recall Tamir.^[8] On order from the Minister, Avigdor Lieberman, Tamir was called in for a clarification meeting with the Ministry's director general, Yossi Gal. Tamir claimed in the meeting that the intent of the letter was to point out a problematic situation with the Administration, which could be better handled. He did not intend to make it public, he claimed. To the point of the matter, Tamir thought that the manner by which the relations were handled could jeopardize the intimacy of relations which had been built in a course of many years; and defeat the principal of leaving the Israel topic outside and above the US policies, which would also diminish the relation of the American Jewry with the State of Israel. Some people familiar with the field expressed the opinion, that those processes have actually occurred.^[9][10]

The Prime Minister's office officially stated that "The letter is not worth a response"; However, a top official of the office said, off the record, that the letter was written with negligence, that it expressed a private political opinion by the writer, whose intention was to hurt the State of Israel, and that it was a shame that it had been written.^[11] The leaders of the Jewish communities in the New England area published letters supporting Tamir, and asked that he retain his position.^[3][12] US government officials also supported Tamir.^[13] Indeed, Tamir fulfilled his term as consul general.

Nadav Tamir at the AIPAC Committee, 2013, with presidents Shimon Peres and Barack Obama

Relations with the Jewish community

Tamir has acted to strengthen ties between Israel and the local Jewry. He initiated a new approach for connecting the two bodies, through out-of-politics channels, around what Tamir called "Jewish Peopleness", and the image of "The Big Tent" which contains all community members, including those who have conflicts with the Israeli government. Some of the community leaders stated that Tamir made the Consulate a central factor in advancing economic activities between Israel and the New England states, which are national leaders in Life Sciences and Hi-Tech industries.

Nadav Tamir advising to the President of Israel, Shimon Peres

Adviser to the President

After completing his duty as consul, Tamir joined the Policy Planning unit of the Foreign Ministry in Jerusalem. Today Tamir is known as one of the top experts in Israel on Israel–United States relations.

In his position as the President's adviser, Tamir was responsible for the diplomatic meetings of the President in Israel and abroad, and he advised the President on topics related to foreign policy, and relations between Israel and Jewish communities around the world.