Mrs. Howard Maxwell

On May 14, 1951, the Mecklenburg County Police Department were called in the afternoon about a suspected murder that had occurred in Charlotte. The caller said that her granddaughter, 4-year-old Diane Maxwell, whose head was cut and bloodied, told her that a man had burgled into their home and "cut" her mother. Upon arriving at the scene, patrolmen discovered a grisly scene: Mrs. Maxwell was found lying in a pool of her own blood, with stab wounds over her left eye that penetrated into her brain and another into her breast. In addition, her throat had been cut from side to side, leaving a deep gash on it.^[1] In the subsequent autopsy, the coroner determined that the woman had been attacked while she was in bed, with the killer attempting to slash her daughter, who slept in another bed across the room. In a near miraculous feat, it was said that despite her fatal injuries, Mrs. Maxwell stood up and walked to her daughter's side and stood for a second before collapsing to the ground. The murder weapon was supposedly a knife, with either a gap in the blade or a dull end, as there were notable irregularities in the victim's wounds.^[1]

While the killer had left little in the way of physical evidence, witnesses recalled seeing a black man walking towards the Maxwell household, and later fleeing after the killing. In the following weeks, hundreds of potential suspects were questioned, and on May 27, 1951, police stopped a car whose occupants were suspected of being drunk. When they saw that the driver, Nathaniel Lipscomb, tried to throw away what looked like a dagger, he was arrested for driving without a license and carrying a concealed weapon. The day after his arrest, Lipscomb unexpectedly confessed to killing Maxwell, but claimed it had been an accident: according to his claims, he knocked on the door of the Maxwell home to ask for a drink of water, but when nobody answered, he entered inside.^[1] At that time, Mrs. Maxwell awoke and attacked him, and, in the ensuing struggle, he accidentally slashed her throat. To prove his guilt, he offered to take them to his family home, where he presented them with a pearl-handled knife, hidden in a box stored in the garage, claiming that it was the murder weapon. Detectives dismissed his claim, but upon examining the dagger he had discarded, which was dulled, they began to take his claims seriously.^[1] However, much to their dismay, Nathaniel retracted his confession, and in the weeks following, he shifted between confessing and denying the murder. During the month of June, he was ordered to undertake two lie detector tests, the first which determined that he was probably the killer, while the other - that he wasn't. While they had issues proving whether he was guilty or not, the detectives realized that their suspect was likely mentally unwell, and so, they took him to the Charlotte Mental Health Clinic for a psychiatric evaluation. After several examinations, clinic officials reported that Lipscomb was an impulsive sexual degenerate and mentally handicapped, with a predisposition for molesting others.^[1] He was sent for a second round of evaluations at the Cherry Hospital in Goldsboro, where doctors determined that while he had a low IQ (a total of 51), he didn't suffer from any visual disorders and was capable of distinguishing right from wrong. Despite this, police officials doubted that they would convict him, and requested that he be detained in the clinic as a "criminally dangerous person".^[4]

In October, Lipscomb was released from Cherry Hospital, and subsequently vanished. Upon learning this, authorities searched for him at his family home, where his sister and mother lived, but they told them that they had run him off, as they were afraid of him. According to his mother, he claimed that he was going to Norfolk, Virginia in search of a job. For the next eight years, Lipscomb remained under the radar, until his arrest as suspect in three rape-murders.^[4]

The Dawn Strangler

Between December 1958 and April 1959, Baltimore was struck by a series of mysterious killings, always aimed at older women who lived within several blocks of one another. Each victim was found beaten, raped and subsequently strangled in an alley near their homes. Since all of them showed signs of being committed by the same offender, the killer was nicknamed "The Dawn Strangler", as his crimes always happened in the early morning.^[5]

The first victim was 38-year-old black woman Mae Hall, whose body was found in a neighbor's yard on 1300 East Eager Street on December 9, 1958. She had been strangled to death, and it was determined that she had been dead for at least several days prior to the body's discovery.^[3] Five days later, 57-year-old Lottie Kight, a white practical nurse, left in the early morning to sweep the sidewalk in front of her house. About two hours later, her body was found two doors away in a narrow alleyway, with a handkerchief wrapped around her neck. Her fists were clenched and fingers bloodied, indicating that she unsuccessfully tried to resist her attacker. Authorities started questioning various suspects about the killing, making several undergo lie detector tests, but all were eventually released, with the murders halting at a standstill.^[3] It was until April 9 of the following year, when the body of 38-year-old Pearl Weiss, another black woman, was found in an alleyway only five blocks away from where Kight had been murdered. She had been strangled, her neck bruised and her fingers bloodied, with her killer apparently stealing her shoes.^[3]