History | |
---|---|
Established by | Joe Biden on April 9, 2021 |
Disbanded | December 8, 2021 |
Related Executive Order number(s) | 14023 |
Membership | |
Chairperson | Robert Bauer Cristina M. Rodríguez |
The Presidential Commission on the Supreme Court of the United States (PCSCOTUS), also known informally as the Supreme Court commission, was a Presidential Commission established by U.S. President Joe Biden to investigate the idea of reforming the Supreme Court. It was slated to provide a nonpartisan analysis of "the principal arguments in the contemporary public debate for and against Supreme Court reform".[1] The commission was established through Executive Order 14023, issued on April 9, 2021.[2] The order determined that the commission must issue a report within 180 days of its first public meeting,[1] which took place May 19, 2021.[3] The commission issued its final report on December 8, 2021.
Origins
Politicization of the Supreme Court
Months before the commission was established, Amy Coney Barrett had been nominated to the Supreme Court by then-president Donald Trump.[4] This nomination was controversial. In 2016, Republicans had invoked the informal and seldom-used Thurmond rule to block the nomination of Merrick Garland, based on its proximity to a presidential election.[5] Garland's nomination had come nearly 10 months before the 2016 United States presidential election. However, Trump's nomination of Barrett came just over one month before the 2020 United States presidential election, and was appointed to the court. Many Democrats interpreted this as unjust, and proof of politicization in Supreme Court nominations.[6] This grievance, along with the Republicans' resulting 6-3 majority, led to pressure from some Democrats to respond accordingly.[7]
Proposals from Democrats
During the 2020 Democratic primaries, Pete Buttigieg proposed that the size of the Supreme Court be increased to 15, in order to reduce the significance of partisanship. He described the proposal as "no more a departure from norms than what the Republicans did to get the judiciary to the place it is today”.[8]
Rather than a specific proposal, Biden signaled the idea of the commission on the 2020 campaign trail, saying the court was "getting out of whack". Biden also stated that "it’s not about court-packing,” adding that "there’s a number of other things that our constitutional scholars have debated… the last thing we need to do is turn the Supreme Court into just a political football".[9] Biden won the Democratic primary, and then the 2020 United States presidency.
Commencement
The commission was established on April 9, 2021. An editorial of The Wall Street Journal wrote that the commission's membership "tilts sharply to the legal and political left",[10] and the libertarian Cato Institute estimated the ratio of progressives to conservatives as 3:1.[11] However, an article in Vox described the membership as a "win for the [conservative] Federalist Society", saying that "while the author of one of the most significant attacks on Obamacare in the last decade [Thomas B. Griffith] is on Biden’s commission, none of the leading academic proponents of Supreme Court reform were appointed". These leading academic proponents included Daniel Epps and Ganesh Sitaraman, who had authored Pete Buttigieg's proposal to expand the Supreme Court, but were not invited to the commission.[12]
Report
The final report was submitted to President Biden on December 7, 2021 with unanimous approval.[13]
The 300-page final report reviewed the history and legal significance of various questions around the Supreme Court, but did not support any structural changes.[14] While it was generally supportive of allowing TV cameras in the courtroom, it did not take a position on issues such as term limits or expanding the court.[13]
Biden had not asked the commission for recommendations, and did not commit to a specific timeline to review the report. This led to criticism that the report was not seriously intended to improve the institution. Some progressive members of the commission specified that their approval was to submit the report to Biden, not a vote to retain the status quo.[14]
As of 2024, no legal reforms have resulted from the commission.
Members
Member | Role | Relevant experience | Appointed | Left commission |
---|---|---|---|---|
Robert Bauer | Co-chair | Former White House Counsel | April 9, 2021 | December 18, 2021 |
Cristina M. Rodríguez | Co-chair | Professor at Yale Law School | April 9, 2021 | December 18, 2021 |
Michelle Adams | Member | Professor at the Cardozo School of Law | April 9, 2021 | December 18, 2021 |
Kate Andrias | Rapporteur | Professor at Michigan Law School | April 9, 2021 | December 18, 2021 |
Jack Balkin | Member | Professor at Yale Law School | April 9, 2021 | October 2021 |
William Baude | Member | Professor at the University of Chicago Law School | April 9, 2021 | December 18, 2021 |
Guy-Uriel E. Charles | Member | Professor at Duke Law School | April 9, 2021 | December 18, 2021 |
Andrew Manuel Crespo | Member | Professor at Harvard Law School | April 9, 2021 | December 18, 2021 |
Walter E. Dellinger III | Member | Professor at Duke Law School; former Acting Solicitor General of the United States | April 9, 2021 | December 18, 2021 |
Justin Driver | Member | Professor at Yale Law School | April 9, 2021 | December 18, 2021 |
Richard H. Fallon Jr. | Member | Professor at Harvard Law School | April 9, 2021 | December 18, 2021 |
Caroline Fredrickson | Member | Former president of the American Constitution Society | April 9, 2021 | December 18, 2021 |
Heather K. Gerken | Member | Dean of Yale Law School | April 9, 2021 | December 18, 2021 |
Nancy Gertner | Member | Former judge of the United States District Court for the District of Massachusetts | April 9, 2021 | December 18, 2021 |
Jack Goldsmith | Member | Professor at Harvard Law School; former United States Assistant Attorney General for the Office of Legal Counsel | April 9, 2021 | October 2021 |
Thomas B. Griffith | Member | Former judge of the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit | April 9, 2021 | December 18, 2021 |
Tara Leigh Grove | Member | Professor at the University of Alabama Law School | April 9, 2021 | December 18, 2021 |
Bert Huang | Member | Professor at Columbia Law School | April 9, 2021 | December 18, 2021 |
Sherrilyn Ifill | Member | President of the NAACP Legal Defense Fund | April 9, 2021 | December 18, 2021 |
Olatunde C. Johnson | Member | Professor at Columbia Law School | April 9, 2021 | December 18, 2021 |
Michael S. Kang | Member | Professor at Northwestern Law School | April 9, 2021 | December 18, 2021 |
Alison LaCroix | Member | Professor at the University of Chicago Law School | April 9, 2021 | December 18, 2021 |
Margaret H. Lemos | Member | Professor at Duke Law School | April 9, 2021 | December 18, 2021 |
David F. Levi | Member | Former dean of Duke Law School; former chief judge of the United States District Court for the Eastern District of California; former judge of the United States District Court for the Eastern District of California; former United States Attorney for the Eastern District of California | April 9, 2021 | December 18, 2021 |
Trevor Morrison | Member | Dean of the New York University School of Law | April 9, 2021 | December 18, 2021 |
Caleb Nelson | Member | Professor at the University of Virginia Law School | April 9, 2021 | October 2021 |
Richard Pildes | Member | Professor at the New York University School of Law | April 9, 2021 | December 18, 2021 |
Michael D. Ramsey | Member | Professor at the University of San Diego Law School | April 9, 2021 | December 18, 2021 |
Kermit Roosevelt III | Member | Professor at the University of Pennsylvania Law School; great-great-grandson of Theodore Roosevelt | April 9, 2021 | December 18, 2021 |
Bertrall Ross | Member | Professor at the UC Berkeley School of Law | April 9, 2021 | December 18, 2021 |
David A. Strauss | Member | Professor at the University of Chicago Law School | April 9, 2021 | December 18, 2021 |
Laurence Tribe | Member | Professor at Harvard Law School; co-founder of the American Constitution Society | April 9, 2021 | December 18, 2021 |
Adam White | Member | Resident scholar at the American Enterprise Institute | April 9, 2021 | December 18, 2021 |
Keith Whittington | Member | Professor at Princeton University | April 9, 2021 | December 18, 2021 |
Michael Waldman | Member | President of the Brennan Center for Justice; former White House Director of Speechwriting | April 9, 2021 | December 18, 2021 |
Two of the commission's members, Caleb Nelson and Jack Goldsmith, had resigned their positions by October 2021.[15]
See also
References
- 1 2 "President Biden to Sign Executive Order Creating the Presidential Commission on the Supreme Court of the United States". whitehouse.gov. April 9, 2021. Retrieved April 9, 2021.
- ↑ Establishment of the Presidential Commission on the Supreme Court of the United States from the Federal Register
- ↑ May 19, 2021 from whitehouse.gov
- ↑ "Biden assigns study on delicate issue of Supreme Court". Associated Press. April 9, 2021. Retrieved April 9, 2021.
- ↑ "What every Republican senator has said about filling a Supreme Court vacancy in an election year". PBS NewsHour. September 19, 2020. Retrieved August 14, 2023.
- ↑ Biskupic, Joan (January 30, 2021). "Biden's Supreme Court commission set to launch as some liberals are eager to pack the court | CNN Politics". CNN. Retrieved August 14, 2023.
- ↑ "Wisconsin Democrats combat threatened impeachment of court justice with $4M effort". ABC News. Retrieved September 12, 2023.
- ↑ Millhiser, Ian (October 30, 2019). "Pete Buttigieg longs for a non-political Supreme Court. That's not really possible". Vox. Retrieved August 14, 2023.
- ↑ Vazquez, Maegan (October 13, 2021). "White House commission on the Supreme Court to release draft materials Thursday | CNN Politics". CNN. Retrieved August 14, 2023.
- ↑ The Editorial Board (April 9, 2021). "Opinion | Biden Commissions the Supreme Court". The Wall Street Journal. ISSN 0099-9660. Retrieved August 14, 2023.
- ↑ "Biden's Supreme Court Commission: Who's On It and Why Explained". news.bloomberglaw.com. Retrieved August 14, 2023.
- ↑ Millhiser, Ian (April 10, 2021). "Biden's new Supreme Court commission is a win for the Federalist Society". Vox. Retrieved August 14, 2023.
- 1 2 "Final Report | PCSCOTUS". The White House. Retrieved August 14, 2023.
- 1 2 Kruzel, John (December 7, 2021). "Biden Supreme Court study panel unanimously approves final report". The Hill. Retrieved August 14, 2023.
- ↑ "Biden's Supreme Court Commission Loses Two Conservatives (2)". Bloomberg. October 15, 2021. Retrieved April 4, 2022.