Background and childhood hardship

Seven-year-old Chaplin (centre, head slightly cocked) at the Central London District School for paupers, 1897

Charles Spencer Chaplin Jr. was born on 16 April 1889 to Hannah Chaplin (née Hill) and Charles Chaplin Sr. His paternal grandmother came from the Smith family, who belonged to Romani people.^[1][2][3][4] There is no official record of his birth, although Chaplin believed he was born at East Street, Walworth, in South London.^{[5][lower-alpha 1]} His parents had married four years previously, at which time Charles Sr. became the legal guardian of Hannah's first son, Sydney John Hill.^{[9][lower-alpha 2]} At the time of his birth, Chaplin's parents were both music hall entertainers. Hannah, the daughter of a shoemaker,^[10] had a brief and unsuccessful career under the stage name Lily Harley,^[11] while Charles Sr., a butcher's son,^[12] was a popular singer.^[13] Although they never divorced, Chaplin's parents were estranged by around 1891.^[14] The following year, Hannah gave birth to a third son, George Wheeler Dryden, fathered by the music hall entertainer Leo Dryden. The child was taken by Dryden at six months old, and did not re-enter Chaplin's life for thirty years.^[15]

Chaplin's childhood was fraught with poverty and hardship, making his eventual trajectory "the most dramatic of all the rags to riches stories ever told" according to his authorised biographer David Robinson.^[16] Chaplin's early years were spent with his mother and brother Sydney in the London district of Kennington. Hannah had no means of income, other than occasional nursing and dressmaking, and Chaplin Sr. provided no financial support.^[17] As the situation deteriorated, Chaplin was sent to Lambeth Workhouse when he was seven years old.^{[lower-alpha 3]} The council housed him at the Central London District School for paupers, which Chaplin remembered as "a forlorn existence".^[19] He was briefly reunited with his mother 18 months later, but Hannah was forced to readmit her family to the workhouse in July 1898. The boys were promptly sent to Norwood Schools, another institution for destitute children.^[20]

I was hardly aware of a crisis because we lived in a continual crisis; and, being a boy, I dismissed our troubles with gracious forgetfulness.

— Charlie Chaplin, on his childhood^[21]

In September 1898, Hannah was committed to Cane Hill mental asylum; she had developed a psychosis seemingly brought on by an infection of syphilis and malnutrition.^[22] For the two months she was there, Chaplin and his brother Sydney were sent to live with their father, whom the young boys scarcely knew.^[23] Charles Sr. was by then severely alcoholic, and life there was bad enough to provoke a visit from the National Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children.^[24] Chaplin's father died two years later, at 38 years old, from cirrhosis of the liver.^[25]

Hannah entered a period of remission but, in May 1903, became ill again.^[24] Chaplin, then 14, had the task of taking his mother to the infirmary, from where she was sent back to Cane Hill.^[26] He lived alone for several days, searching for food and occasionally sleeping rough, until Sydney – who had joined the Navy two years earlier – returned.^[27] Hannah was released from the asylum eight months later,^[28] but in March 1905, her illness returned, this time permanently. "There was nothing we could do but accept poor mother's fate", Chaplin later wrote, and she remained in care until her death in 1928.^[29]

Young performer

A teenage Chaplin in the play Sherlock Holmes

Between his time in the poor schools and his mother succumbing to mental illness, Chaplin began to perform on stage. He later recalled making his first amateur appearance at the age of five years, when he took over from Hannah one night in Aldershot.^{[lower-alpha 4]} This was an isolated occurrence, but by the time he was nine Chaplin had, with his mother's encouragement, grown interested in performing. He later wrote: "[she] imbued me with the feeling that I had some sort of talent".^[31] Through his father's connections,^[32] Chaplin became a member of the Eight Lancashire Lads clog-dancing troupe, with whom he toured English music halls throughout 1899 and 1900.^{[lower-alpha 5]} Chaplin worked hard, and the act was popular with audiences, but he was not satisfied with dancing and wished to form a comedy act.^[34]

In the years Chaplin was touring with the Eight Lancashire Lads, his mother ensured that he still attended school but, by the age of 13, he had abandoned education.^[35][36] He supported himself with a range of jobs, while nursing his ambition to become an actor.^[37] At 14, shortly after his mother's relapse, he registered with a theatrical agency in London's West End. The manager sensed potential in Chaplin, who was promptly given his first role as a newsboy in Harry Arthur Saintsbury's Jim, a Romance of Cockayne.^[38] It opened in July 1903, but the show was unsuccessful and closed after two weeks. Chaplin's comic performance, however, was singled out for praise in many of the reviews.^[39]

Saintsbury secured a role for Chaplin in Charles Frohman's production of Sherlock Holmes, where he played Billy the pageboy in three nationwide tours.^[40] His performance was so well received that he was called to London to play the role alongside William Gillette, the original Holmes.^{[lower-alpha 6]} "It was like tidings from heaven", Chaplin recalled.^[42] At 16 years old, Chaplin starred in the play's West End production at the Duke of York's Theatre from October to December 1905.^[43] He completed one final tour of Sherlock Holmes in early 1906, before leaving the play after more than two-and-a-half years.^[44]

Stage comedy and vaudeville

Chaplin soon found work with a new company and went on tour with his brother, who was also pursuing an acting career, in a comedy sketch called Repairs.^[45] In May 1906, Chaplin joined the juvenile act Casey's Circus,^[46] where he developed popular burlesque pieces and was soon the star of the show. By the time the act finished touring in July 1907, the 18-year-old had become an accomplished comedic performer.^[47] He struggled to find more work, however, and a brief attempt at a solo act was a failure.^{[lower-alpha 7]}

Advertisement from Chaplin's American tour with the Fred Karno comedy company, 1913

Meanwhile, Sydney Chaplin had joined Fred Karno's prestigious comedy company in 1906 and, by 1908, he was one of their key performers.^[49] In February, he managed to secure a two-week trial for his younger brother. Karno was initially wary, and considered Chaplin a "pale, puny, sullen-looking youngster" who "looked much too shy to do any good in the theatre".^[50] However, the teenager made an impact on his first night at the London Coliseum and he was quickly signed to a contract.^[51] Chaplin began by playing a series of minor parts, eventually progressing to starring roles in 1909.^[52] In April 1910, he was given the lead in a new sketch, Jimmy the Fearless. It was a big success, and Chaplin received considerable press attention.^[53]

Karno selected his new star to join the section of the company, one that also included Stan Laurel, that toured North America's vaudeville circuit.^[54][55] The young comedian headed the show and impressed reviewers, being described as "one of the best pantomime artists ever seen here".^[56] His most successful role was a drunk called the "Inebriate Swell", which drew him significant recognition.^[57] The tour lasted 21 months, and the troupe returned to England in June 1912.^[58] Chaplin recalled that he "had a disquieting feeling of sinking back into a depressing commonplaceness" and was, therefore, delighted when a new tour began in October.^[59]

Keystone

Six months into the second American tour, Chaplin was invited to join the New York Motion Picture Company. A representative who had seen his performances thought he could replace Fred Mace, a star of their Keystone Studios who intended to leave.^[60] Chaplin thought the Keystone comedies "a crude mélange of rough and rumble", but liked the idea of working in films and rationalised: "Besides, it would mean a new life."^[61] He met with the company and signed a $150-per-week^{[lower-alpha 8]} contract in September 1913.^[63] Chaplin arrived in Los Angeles in early December,^[64] and began working for the Keystone studio on 5 January 1914.^[65]

Chaplin (left) in his first film appearance, Making a Living, with Henry Lehrman who directed the picture (1914)

Chaplin's trademark character "the Tramp" debuts in Kid Auto Races at Venice (1914), Chaplin's second released film

Chaplin's boss was Mack Sennett, who initially expressed concern that the 24-year-old looked too young.^[66] He was not used in a picture until late January, during which time Chaplin attempted to learn the processes of filmmaking.^[67] The one-reeler Making a Living marked his film acting debut and was released on 2 February 1914. Chaplin strongly disliked the picture, but one review picked him out as "a comedian of the first water".^[68] For his second appearance in front of the camera, Chaplin selected the costume with which he became identified. He described the process in his autobiography:

I wanted everything to be a contradiction: the pants baggy, the coat tight, the hat small and the shoes large ... I added a small moustache, which, I reasoned, would add age without hiding my expression. I had no idea of the character. But the moment I was dressed, the clothes and the makeup made me feel the person he was. I began to know him, and by the time I walked on stage he was fully born.^{[69][lower-alpha 9]}

The film was Mabel's Strange Predicament, but "the Tramp" character, as it became known, debuted to audiences in Kid Auto Races at Venice – shot later than Mabel's Strange Predicament but released two days earlier on 7 February 1914.^[71][72] Chaplin adopted the character as his screen persona and attempted to make suggestions for the films he appeared in. These ideas were dismissed by his directors.^[73] During the filming of his 11th picture, Mabel at the Wheel, he clashed with director Mabel Normand and was almost released from his contract. Sennett kept him on, however, when he received orders from exhibitors for more Chaplin films.^[74] Sennett also allowed Chaplin to direct his next film himself after Chaplin promised to pay $1,500 ($44,000 in 2022 dollars) if the film was unsuccessful.^[75]

Caught in the Rain, issued 4 May 1914, was Chaplin's directorial debut and was highly successful.^[76] Thereafter he directed almost every short film in which he appeared for Keystone,^[77] at the rate of approximately one per week,^[78] a period which he later remembered as the most exciting time of his career.^[79] Chaplin's films introduced a slower form of comedy than the typical Keystone farce,^[71] and he developed a large fan base.^[80] In November 1914, he had a supporting role in the first feature length comedy film, Tillie's Punctured Romance, directed by Sennett and starring Marie Dressler, which was a commercial success and increased his popularity.^[81] When Chaplin's contract came up for renewal at the end of the year, he asked for $1,000 a week,^{[lower-alpha 10]} an amount Sennett refused as he thought it was too large.^[82]

Essanay

Chaplin and Edna Purviance, his regular leading lady, in Work (1915)

The Essanay Film Manufacturing Company of Chicago sent Chaplin an offer of $1,250^{[lower-alpha 11]} a week with a signing bonus of $10,000.^{[lower-alpha 12]} He joined the studio in late December 1914,^[83] where he began forming a stock company of regular players, actors he worked with again and again, including Ben Turpin, Leo White, Bud Jamison, Paddy McGuire, Fred Goodwins, and Billy Armstrong. He soon recruited a leading lady, Edna Purviance, whom Chaplin met in a café and hired on account of her beauty. She went on to appear in 35 films with Chaplin over eight years;^[84] the pair also formed a romantic relationship that lasted until 1917.^[85]

Chaplin asserted a high level of control over his pictures and started to put more time and care into each film.^[86] There was a month-long interval between the release of his second production, A Night Out, and his third, The Champion.^[87] The final seven of Chaplin's 14 Essanay films were all produced at this slower pace.^[88] Chaplin also began to alter his screen persona, which had attracted some criticism at Keystone for its "mean, crude, and brutish" nature.^[89] The character became more gentle and romantic;^[90] The Tramp (April 1915) was considered a particular turning point in his development.^[91] The use of pathos was developed further with The Bank, in which Chaplin created a sad ending. Robinson notes that this was an innovation in comedy films, and marked the time when serious critics began to appreciate Chaplin's work.^[92] At Essanay, writes film scholar Simon Louvish, Chaplin "found the themes and the settings that would define the Tramp's world".^[93]

During 1915, Chaplin became a cultural phenomenon. Shops were stocked with Chaplin merchandise, he was featured in cartoons and comic strips, and several songs were written about him.^[94] In July, a journalist for Motion Picture Magazine wrote that "Chaplinitis" had spread across America.^[95] As his fame grew worldwide, he became the film industry's first international star.^[96] When the Essanay contract ended in December 1915,^{[97][lower-alpha 13]} Chaplin, fully aware of his popularity, requested a $150,000^{[lower-alpha 14]} signing bonus from his next studio. He received several offers, including Universal, Fox, and Vitagraph, the best of which came from the Mutual Film Corporation at $10,000^{[lower-alpha 15]} a week.^[99]

Mutual

By 1916, Chaplin was a global phenomenon. Here he shows off some of his merchandise, c. 1918.

A contract was negotiated with Mutual that amounted to $670,000^{[lower-alpha 16]} a year,^[100] which Robinson says made Chaplin – at 26 years old – one of the highest-paid people in the world.^[101] The high salary shocked the public and was widely reported in the press.^[102] John R. Freuler, the studio president, explained: "We can afford to pay Mr. Chaplin this large sum annually because the public wants Chaplin and will pay for him."^[103]

Mutual gave Chaplin his own Los Angeles studio to work in, which opened in March 1916.^[104] He added two key members to his stock company, Albert Austin and Eric Campbell,^[105] and produced a series of elaborate two-reelers: The Floorwalker, The Fireman, The Vagabond, One A.M., and The Count.^[106] For The Pawnshop, he recruited the actor Henry Bergman, who was to work with Chaplin for 30 years.^[107] Behind the Screen and The Rink completed Chaplin's releases for 1916. The Mutual contract stipulated that he release a two-reel film every four weeks, which he had managed to achieve. With the new year, however, Chaplin began to demand more time.^[108] He made only four more films for Mutual over the first ten months of 1917: Easy Street, The Cure, The Immigrant, and The Adventurer.^[109] With their careful construction, these films are considered by Chaplin scholars to be among his finest work.^[110][111] Later in life, Chaplin referred to his Mutual years as the happiest period of his career.^[112] However, Chaplin also felt that those films became increasingly formulaic over the period of the contract, and he was increasingly dissatisfied with the working conditions encouraging that.^[113]

Chaplin was attacked in the British media for not fighting in the First World War.^[114] He defended himself, claiming that he would fight for Britain if called and had registered for the American draft, but he was not summoned by either country.^{[lower-alpha 17]} Despite this criticism, Chaplin was a favourite with the troops,^[116] and his popularity continued to grow worldwide. Harper's Weekly reported that the name of Charlie Chaplin was "a part of the common language of almost every country", and that the Tramp image was "universally familiar".^[117] In 1917, professional Chaplin imitators were so widespread that he took legal action,^[118] and it was reported that nine out of ten men who attended costume parties, did so dressed as the Tramp.^[119] The same year, a study by the Boston Society for Psychical Research concluded that Chaplin was "an American obsession".^[119] The actress Minnie Maddern Fiske wrote that "a constantly increasing body of cultured, artistic people are beginning to regard the young English buffoon, Charles Chaplin, as an extraordinary artist, as well as a comic genius".^[117]

United Artists, Mildred Harris, and The Kid

After the release of Shoulder Arms, Chaplin requested more money from First National, which was refused. Frustrated with their lack of concern for quality, and worried about rumours of a possible merger between the company and Famous Players–Lasky, Chaplin joined forces with Douglas Fairbanks, Mary Pickford, and D. W. Griffith to form a new distribution company, United Artists, in January 1919.^[132] The arrangement was revolutionary in the film industry, as it enabled the four partners – all creative artists – to personally fund their pictures and have complete control.^[133] Chaplin was eager to start with the new company and offered to buy out his contract with First National. They refused and insisted that he complete the final six films owed.^[134]

The Kid (1921), with Jackie Coogan, combined comedy with drama and was Chaplin's first film to exceed an hour.

Before the creation of United Artists, Chaplin married for the first time. The 16-year-old actress Mildred Harris had revealed that she was pregnant with his child, and in September 1918, he married her quietly in Los Angeles to avoid controversy.^[135] Soon after, the pregnancy was found to be false.^[136] Chaplin was unhappy with the union and, feeling that marriage stunted his creativity, struggled over the production of his film Sunnyside.^[137] Harris was by then legitimately pregnant, and on 7 July 1919, gave birth to a son. Norman Spencer Chaplin was born malformed and died three days later.^[138] The marriage ended in April 1920, with Chaplin explaining in his autobiography that they were "irreconcilably mismated".^[139]

Losing the child, plus his own childhood experiences, are thought to have influenced Chaplin's next film, which turned the Tramp into the caretaker of a young boy.^[125][140] For this new venture, Chaplin also wished to do more than comedy and, according to Louvish, "make his mark on a changed world".^[141] Filming on The Kid began in August 1919, with four-year-old Jackie Coogan his co-star.^[142] The Kid was in production for nine months until May 1920 and, at 68 minutes, it was Chaplin's longest picture to date.^[143] Dealing with issues of poverty and parent–child separation, The Kid was one of the earliest films to combine comedy and drama.^[144] It was released in January 1921 with instant success, and, by 1924, had been screened in over 50 countries.^[145]

Chaplin spent five months on his next film, the two-reeler The Idle Class.^[133] Work on the picture was for a time delayed by more turmoil in his personal life. First National had on 12 April announced Chaplin's engagement to the actress May Collins, whom he had hired to be his secretary at the studio. By early June, however, Chaplin "suddenly decided he could scarcely stand to be in the same room" as Collins, but instead of breaking off the engagement directly, he "stopped coming in to work, sending word that he was suffering from a bad case of influenza, which May knew to be a lie."^[146]

Ultimately work on the film resumed, and following its September 1921 release, Chaplin chose to return to England for the first time in almost a decade.^[147] He wrote a book about his journey, titled My Wonderful Visit.^[148] He then worked to fulfil his First National contract, releasing Pay Day in February 1922. The Pilgrim, his final short film, was delayed by distribution disagreements with the studio and released a year later.^[149]

A Woman of Paris and The Gold Rush

Having fulfilled his First National contract, Chaplin was free to make his first picture as an independent producer. In November 1922, he began filming A Woman of Paris, a romantic drama about ill-fated lovers.^[150] Chaplin intended it to be a star-making vehicle for Edna Purviance,^[151] and did not appear in the picture himself other than in a brief, uncredited cameo.^[152] He wished the film to have a realistic feel and directed his cast to give restrained performances. In real life, he explained, "men and women try to hide their emotions rather than seek to express them".^[153] A Woman of Paris premiered in September 1923 and was acclaimed for its innovative, subtle approach.^[154] The public, however, seemed to have little interest in a Chaplin film without Chaplin, and it was a box office disappointment.^[155] The filmmaker was hurt by this failure – he had long wanted to produce a dramatic film and was proud of the result – and soon withdrew A Woman of Paris from circulation.^[156]

The Tramp resorts to eating his boot in The Gold Rush (1925).

Chaplin returned to comedy for his next project. Setting his standards high, he told himself "This next film must be an epic! The Greatest!"^[157] Inspired by a photograph of the 1898 Klondike Gold Rush, and later the story of the Donner Party of 1846–1847, he made what Geoffrey Macnab calls "an epic comedy out of grim subject matter".^[158] In The Gold Rush, the Tramp is a lonely prospector fighting adversity and looking for love. With Georgia Hale as his leading lady, Chaplin began filming the picture in February 1924.^[159] Its elaborate production, costing almost $1 million,^[160] included location shooting in the Truckee mountains in Nevada with 600 extras, extravagant sets, and special effects.^[161] The last scene was shot in May 1925 after 15 months of filming.^[162]

Chaplin felt The Gold Rush was the best film he had made.^[163] It opened in August 1925 and became one of the highest-grossing films of the silent era with a U.S. box-office of $5 million.^{[lower-alpha 19][164]} The comedy contains some of Chaplin's most famous sequences, such as the Tramp eating his shoe and the "Dance of the Rolls".^[165] Macnab has called it "the quintessential Chaplin film".^[166] Chaplin stated at its release, "This is the picture that I want to be remembered by".^[167]

Lita Grey and The Circus

Lita Grey, whose bitter divorce from Chaplin caused a scandal

While making The Gold Rush, Chaplin married for the second time. Mirroring the circumstances of his first union, Lita Grey was a teenage actress, originally set to star in the film, whose surprise announcement of pregnancy forced Chaplin into marriage. She was 16 and he was 35, meaning Chaplin could have been charged with statutory rape under California law.^[168] He therefore arranged a discreet marriage in Mexico on 25 November 1924.^[169] They originally met during her childhood and she had previously appeared in his works The Kid and The Idle Class.^[170] Their first son, Charles Spencer Chaplin III, was born on 5 May 1925, followed by Sydney Earl Chaplin on 30 March 1926.^[171] On 6 July 1925, Chaplin became the first movie star to be featured on a Time magazine cover.^[172]

It was an unhappy marriage, and Chaplin spent long hours at the studio to avoid seeing his wife.^[173] In November 1926, Grey took the children and left the family home.^[174] A bitter divorce followed, in which Grey's application – accusing Chaplin of infidelity, abuse, and of harbouring "perverted sexual desires" – was leaked to the press.^{[175][lower-alpha 20]} Chaplin was reported to be in a state of nervous breakdown, as the story became headline news and groups formed across America calling for his films to be banned.^[177] Eager to end the case without further scandal, Chaplin's lawyers agreed to a cash settlement of $600,000^{[lower-alpha 21]} – the largest awarded by American courts at that time.^[178] His fan base was strong enough to survive the incident, and it was soon forgotten, but Chaplin was deeply affected by it.^[179] Less than five months after the divorce, Chaplin and Grey's former butler Don Solovich was murdered in Utah, and articles speculated about connections between Chaplin and the murder.^{[180][181][182]}

Before the divorce suit was filed, Chaplin had begun work on a new film, The Circus.^[183] He built a story around the idea of walking a tightrope while besieged by monkeys, and turned the Tramp into the accidental star of a circus.^[184] Filming was suspended for ten months while he dealt with the divorce scandal,^[185] and it was generally a trouble-ridden production.^[186] Finally completed in October 1927, The Circus was released in January 1928 to a positive reception.^[187] At the 1st Academy Awards, Chaplin was given a special trophy "For versatility and genius in acting, writing, directing and producing The Circus".^[188] Despite its success, he permanently associated the film with the stress of its production; Chaplin omitted The Circus from his autobiography, and struggled to work on it when he recorded the score in his later years.^[189]

City Lights

I was determined to continue making silent films ... I was a pantomimist and in that medium I was unique and, without false modesty, a master.

— Charlie Chaplin, explaining his defiance against sound in the 1930s^[190]

By the time The Circus was released, Hollywood had witnessed the introduction of sound films. Chaplin was cynical about this new medium and the technical shortcomings it presented, believing that "talkies" lacked the artistry of silent films.^[191] He was also hesitant to change the formula that had brought him such success,^[192] and feared that giving the Tramp a voice would limit his international appeal.^[193] He, therefore, rejected the new Hollywood craze and began work on a new silent film. Chaplin was nonetheless anxious about this decision and remained so throughout the film's production.^[193]

City Lights (1931) is regarded as one of Chaplin's finest works.

When filming began at the end of 1928, Chaplin had been working on the story for almost a year.^[194] City Lights followed the Tramp's love for a blind flower girl (played by Virginia Cherrill) and his efforts to raise money for her sight-saving operation. It was a challenging production that lasted 21 months,^[195] with Chaplin later confessing that he "had worked himself into a neurotic state of wanting perfection".^[196] One advantage Chaplin found in sound technology was the opportunity to record a musical score for the film, which he composed himself.^[196][197]

Chaplin finished editing City Lights in December 1930, by which time silent films were an anachronism.^[198] A preview before an unsuspecting public audience was not a success,^[199] but a showing for the press produced positive reviews. One journalist wrote, "Nobody in the world but Charlie Chaplin could have done it. He is the only person that has that peculiar something called 'audience appeal' in sufficient quality to defy the popular penchant for movies that talk."^[200] Given its general release in January 1931, City Lights proved to be a popular and financial success, eventually grossing over $3 million.^{[lower-alpha 22][201]} The British Film Institute called it Chaplin's finest accomplishment, and the critic James Agee hails the closing scene as "the greatest piece of acting and the highest moment in movies".^[202][203] City Lights became Chaplin's personal favourite of his films and remained so throughout his life.^[204]

Travels, Paulette Goddard, and Modern Times

City Lights had been a success, but Chaplin was unsure if he could make another picture without dialogue. He remained convinced that sound would not work in his films, but was also "obsessed by a depressing fear of being old-fashioned".^[205] In this state of uncertainty, early in 1931, the comedian decided to take a holiday and ended up travelling for 16 months.^{[206][lower-alpha 23]} He spent months travelling Western Europe, including extended stays in France and Switzerland, and spontaneously decided to visit Japan.^[208] The day after he arrived in Japan, Prime Minister Inukai Tsuyoshi was assassinated by ultra-nationalists in the May 15 Incident. The group's original plan had been to provoke a war with the United States by assassinating Chaplin at a welcome reception organised by the prime minister, but the plan had been foiled due to delayed public announcement of the event's date.^[209]

Modern Times (1936), described by Jérôme Larcher as a "grim contemplation on the automatization of the individual"^[210]

In his autobiography, Chaplin recalled that on his return to Los Angeles, "I was confused and without plan, restless and conscious of an extreme loneliness". He briefly considered retiring and moving to China.^[211] Chaplin's loneliness was relieved when he met 21-year-old actress Paulette Goddard in July 1932, and the pair began a relationship.^[212] He was not ready to commit to a film, however, and focused on writing a serial about his travels (published in Woman's Home Companion).^[213] The trip had been a stimulating experience for Chaplin, including meetings with several prominent thinkers, and he became increasingly interested in world affairs.^[214] The state of labour in America troubled him, and he feared that capitalism and machinery in the workplace would increase unemployment levels. It was these concerns that stimulated Chaplin to develop his new film.^[215]

Modern Times was announced by Chaplin as "a satire on certain phases of our industrial life".^[216] Featuring the Tramp and Goddard as they endure the Great Depression, it took ten and a half months to film.^[217] Chaplin intended to use spoken dialogue but changed his mind during rehearsals. Like its predecessor, Modern Times employed sound effects but almost no speaking.^[218] Chaplin's performance of a gibberish song did, however, give the Tramp a voice for the only time on film.^[219] After recording the music, Chaplin released Modern Times in February 1936.^[220] It was his first feature in 15 years to adopt political references and social realism,^[221] a factor that attracted considerable press coverage despite Chaplin's attempts to downplay the issue.^[222] The film earned less at the box-office than his previous features and received mixed reviews, as some viewers disliked the politicising.^[223] Today, Modern Times is seen by the British Film Institute as one of Chaplin's "great features",^[202] while David Robinson says it shows the filmmaker at "his unrivalled peak as a creator of visual comedy".^[224]

Following the release of Modern Times, Chaplin left with Goddard for a trip to the Far East.^[225] Chaplin, Goddard, and a Japanese servant named Yonnemori arrived in Saigon at 8:30 am on 13 April 1936, where they stayed at the Continental hotel before going on a trip to visit multiple locations in French Indochina.^[226] After Saigon they visited Phnom Penh to view Angkor Wat, returning to Saigon to go to Da Lat, followed by Huế, arriving in Đà Nẵng at 23 April where he visited the Marble Mountains and the Henri Parmentier Museum.^[226] On 29 April they arrived in Hanoi (the capital city of French Indochina) where they stayed at the Métropole hotel.^[226] In the afternoon of 5 May they visited the popular tourist destination Hạ Long Bay, after visiting Hạ Long Bay the couple left from Hải Phòng to Hong Kong on board of a ship named the Canton.^[226] The couple had refused to comment on the nature of their relationship, and it was not known whether they were married or not.^[227] Sometime later, Chaplin revealed that they married in Canton during this trip.^[228] By 1938, the couple had drifted apart, as both focused heavily on their work, although Goddard was again his leading lady in his next feature film, The Great Dictator. She eventually divorced Chaplin in Mexico in 1942, citing incompatibility and separation for more than a year.^[229]

The Great Dictator

Chaplin satirised Adolf Hitler in The Great Dictator (1940).

The 1940s saw Chaplin face a series of controversies, both in his work and in his personal life, which changed his fortunes and severely affected his popularity in the United States. The first of these was his growing boldness in expressing his political beliefs. Deeply disturbed by the surge of militaristic nationalism in 1930s world politics,^[230] Chaplin found that he could not keep these issues out of his work.^[231] Parallels between himself and Adolf Hitler had been widely noted: the pair were born four days apart, both had risen from poverty to world prominence, and Hitler wore the same moustache style as Chaplin. It was this physical resemblance that supplied the plot for Chaplin's next film, The Great Dictator, which directly satirised Hitler and attacked fascism.^[232]

Chaplin spent two years developing the script^[233] and began filming in September 1939, six days after Britain declared war on Germany.^[234] He had submitted to using spoken dialogue, partly out of acceptance that he had no other choice, but also because he recognised it as a better method for delivering a political message.^[235] Making a comedy about Hitler was seen as highly controversial, but Chaplin's financial independence allowed him to take the risk.^[236] "I was determined to go ahead", he later wrote, "for Hitler must be laughed at."^{[237][lower-alpha 24]} Chaplin replaced the Tramp (while wearing similar attire) with "A Jewish Barber", a reference to the Nazi Party's belief that he was Jewish.^{[238][lower-alpha 25]} In a dual performance, he also played the dictator "Adenoid Hynkel", a parody of Hitler.^[240]

The Great Dictator spent a year in production and was released in October 1940.^[241] The film generated a vast amount of publicity, with a critic for The New York Times calling it "the most eagerly awaited picture of the year", and it was one of the biggest money-makers of the era.^[242] The ending was unpopular, however, and generated controversy.^[243] Chaplin concluded the film with a five-minute speech in which he abandoned his barber character, looked directly into the camera, and pleaded against war and fascism.^[244] Charles J. Maland has identified this overt preaching as triggering a decline in Chaplin's popularity, and writes, "Henceforth, no movie fan would ever be able to separate the dimension of politics from [his] star image".^[245] Nevertheless, both Winston Churchill and Franklin D. Roosevelt liked the film, which they saw at private screenings before its release. Roosevelt subsequently invited Chaplin to read the film's final speech over the radio during his January 1941 inauguration, with the speech becoming a "hit" of the celebration. Chaplin was often invited to other patriotic functions to read the speech to audiences during the years of the war.^[246] The Great Dictator received five Academy Award nominations, including Best Picture, Best Original Screenplay and Best Actor.^[247]

Legal troubles and Oona O'Neill

In the mid-1940s, Chaplin was involved in a series of trials that occupied most of his time and significantly affected his public image.^[248] The troubles stemmed from his affair with an aspiring actress named Joan Barry, with whom he was involved intermittently between June 1941 and the autumn of 1942.^[249] Barry, who displayed obsessive behaviour and was twice arrested after they separated,^{[lower-alpha 26]} reappeared the following year and announced that she was pregnant with Chaplin's child. As Chaplin denied the claim, Barry filed a paternity suit against him.^[250]

The director of the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), J. Edgar Hoover, who had long been suspicious of Chaplin's political leanings, used the opportunity to generate negative publicity about him. As part of a smear campaign to damage Chaplin's image,^[251] the FBI named him in four indictments related to the Barry case. Most serious of these was an alleged violation of the Mann Act, which prohibits the transportation of women across state boundaries for sexual purposes.^{[lower-alpha 27]} Historian Otto Friedrich called this an "absurd prosecution" of an "ancient statute",^[254] yet if Chaplin was found guilty, he faced 23 years in jail.^[255] Three charges lacked sufficient evidence to proceed to court, but the Mann Act trial began on 21 March 1944.^[256] Chaplin was acquitted two weeks later, on 4 April.^[257][252] The case was frequently headline news, with Newsweek calling it the "biggest public relations scandal since the Fatty Arbuckle murder trial in 1921".^[258]

Chaplin's fourth wife and widow, Oona

Barry's child, Carol Ann, was born in October 1943, and the paternity suit went to court in December 1944. After two arduous trials, in which the prosecuting lawyer accused him of "moral turpitude",^[259] Chaplin was declared to be the father. Evidence from blood tests that indicated otherwise were not admissible,^{[lower-alpha 28]} and the judge ordered Chaplin to pay child support until Carol Ann turned 21. Media coverage of the suit was influenced by the FBI, which fed information to gossip columnist Hedda Hopper, and Chaplin was portrayed in an overwhelmingly critical light.^[261]

The controversy surrounding Chaplin increased when – two weeks after the paternity suit was filed – it was announced that he had married his newest protégée, 18-year-old Oona O'Neill, the daughter of American playwright Eugene O'Neill.^[262] Chaplin, then 54, had been introduced to her by a film agent seven months earlier.^{[lower-alpha 29]} In his autobiography, Chaplin described meeting O'Neill as "the happiest event of my life", and claimed to have found "perfect love".^[265] Chaplin's son, Charles III, reported that Oona "worshipped" his father.^[266] The couple remained married until Chaplin's death, and had eight children over 18 years: Geraldine Leigh (b. July 1944), Michael John (b. March 1946), Josephine Hannah (b. March 1949), Victoria Agnes (b. May 1951), Eugene Anthony (b. August 1953), Jane Cecil (b. May 1957), Annette Emily (b. December 1959), and Christopher James (b. July 1962).^[267]

Monsieur Verdoux and communist accusations

Monsieur Verdoux (1947), a dark comedy about a serial killer, marked a significant departure for Chaplin.

Chaplin claimed that the Barry trials had "crippled [his] creativeness", and it was some time before he began working again.^[268] In April 1946, he finally began filming a project that had been in development since 1942.^[269] Monsieur Verdoux was a black comedy, the story of a French bank clerk, Verdoux (Chaplin), who loses his job and begins marrying and murdering wealthy widows to support his family. Chaplin's inspiration for the project came from Orson Welles, who wanted him to star in a film about the French serial killer Henri Désiré Landru. Chaplin decided that the concept would "make a wonderful comedy",^[270] and paid Welles $5,000^{[lower-alpha 30]} for the idea.^[271]

Chaplin again vocalised his political views in Monsieur Verdoux, criticising capitalism and arguing that the world encourages mass killing through wars and weapons of mass destruction.^[272] Because of this, the film met with controversy when it was released in April 1947;^[273] Chaplin was booed at the premiere, and there were calls for a boycott.^[274] Monsieur Verdoux was the first Chaplin release that failed both critically and commercially in the United States.^[275] It was more successful abroad,^[276] and Chaplin's screenplay was nominated at the Academy Awards.^[277] He was proud of the film, writing in his autobiography, "Monsieur Verdoux is the cleverest and most brilliant film I have yet made."^[278]

The negative reaction to Monsieur Verdoux was largely the result of changes in Chaplin's public image.^[279] Along with the damage of the Joan Barry scandal, he was publicly accused of being a communist.^[280] His political activity had heightened during World War II, when he campaigned for the opening of a Second Front to help the Soviet Union and supported various Soviet–American friendship groups.^[281] He was also friendly with several suspected communists, and attended functions given by Soviet diplomats in Los Angeles.^[282] In the political climate of 1940s America, such activities meant Chaplin was considered, as Larcher writes, "dangerously progressive and amoral".^[283] The FBI wanted him out of the country,^[284] and launched an official investigation in early 1947.^{[285][lower-alpha 31]}

Chaplin denied being a communist, instead calling himself a "peacemonger",^[287] but felt the government's effort to suppress the ideology was an unacceptable infringement of civil liberties.^[288] Unwilling to be quiet about the issue, he openly protested against the trials of Communist Party members and the activities of the House Un-American Activities Committee.^[289] Chaplin received a subpoena to appear before HUAC but was not called to testify.^[290] As his activities were widely reported in the press, and Cold War fears grew, questions were raised over his failure to take American citizenship.^[291] Calls were made for him to be deported; in one extreme and widely published example, Representative John E. Rankin, who helped establish HUAC, told Congress in June 1947: "[Chaplin's] very life in Hollywood is detrimental to the moral fabric of America. [If he is deported] ... his loathsome pictures can be kept from before the eyes of the American youth. He should be deported and gotten rid of at once."^[292]

In 2003, declassified British archives belonging to the British Foreign Office revealed that George Orwell secretly accused Chaplin of being a secret communist and a friend of the USSR^[293] in the Orwell's list document. Chaplin's name was one of 35 that Orwell gave to the Information Research Department (IRD), a secret British Cold War propaganda department which worked closely with the CIA.^[293] Chaplin was not the only actor in America whom Orwell accused of being a secret communist.^[293]

Limelight and banning from the United States

Limelight (1952) was a serious and autobiographical film for Chaplin. His character, Calvero, is an ex-music hall star (described in this image as a "Tramp Comedian") forced to deal with his loss of popularity.

Although Chaplin remained politically active in the years following the failure of Monsieur Verdoux,^{[lower-alpha 32]} his next film, about a forgotten music hall comedian and a young ballerina in Edwardian London, was devoid of political themes. Limelight was heavily autobiographical, alluding not only to Chaplin's childhood and the lives of his parents, but also to his loss of popularity in the United States.^[295] The cast included various members of his family, including his five oldest children and his half-brother, Wheeler Dryden.^[296]

Filming began in November 1951, by which time Chaplin had spent three years working on the story.^{[297][lower-alpha 33]} He aimed for a more serious tone than any of his previous films, regularly using the word "melancholy" when explaining his plans to his co-star Claire Bloom.^[299] Limelight featured a cameo appearance from Buster Keaton, whom Chaplin cast as his stage partner in a pantomime scene. This marked the only time the comedians worked together in a feature film.^[300]

Chaplin decided to hold the world premiere of Limelight in London, since it was the setting of the film.^[301] As he left Los Angeles, he expressed a premonition that he would not be returning.^[302] At New York, he boarded the RMS Queen Elizabeth with his family on 18 September 1952.^[303] The next day, United States Attorney General James P. McGranery revoked Chaplin's re-entry permit and stated that he would have to submit to an interview concerning his political views and moral behaviour to re-enter the US.^[303] Although McGranery told the press that he had "a pretty good case against Chaplin", Maland has concluded, on the basis of the FBI files that were released in the 1980s, that the US government had no real evidence to prevent Chaplin's re-entry. It is likely that he would have gained entry if he had applied for it.^[304] However, when Chaplin received a cablegram informing him of the news, he privately decided to cut his ties with the United States:

Whether I re-entered that unhappy country or not was of little consequence to me. I would like to have told them that the sooner I was rid of that hate-beleaguered atmosphere the better, that I was fed up of America's insults and moral pomposity ...^[305]

Because all of his property remained in America, Chaplin refrained from saying anything negative about the incident to the press.^[306] The scandal attracted vast attention,^[307] but Chaplin and his film were warmly received in Europe.^[303] In America, the hostility towards him continued, and, although it received some positive reviews, Limelight was subjected to a wide-scale boycott.^[308] Reflecting on this, Maland writes that Chaplin's fall, from an "unprecedented" level of popularity, "may be the most dramatic in the history of stardom in America".^[309]

Move to Switzerland and A King in New York

I have been the object of lies and propaganda by powerful reactionary groups who, by their influence and by the aid of America's yellow press, have created an unhealthy atmosphere in which liberal-minded individuals can be singled out and persecuted. Under these conditions I find it virtually impossible to continue my motion-picture work, and I have therefore given up my residence in the United States.

— Charlie Chaplin's press release regarding his decision not to seek re‑entry to the US^[310]

Chaplin did not attempt to return to the United States after his re-entry permit was revoked, and instead sent his wife to settle his affairs.^{[lower-alpha 34]} The couple decided to settle in Switzerland and, in January 1953, the family moved into their permanent home: Manoir de Ban, a 14-hectare (35-acre) estate^[312] overlooking Lake Geneva in Corsier-sur-Vevey.^{[313][lower-alpha 35]} Chaplin put his Beverly Hills house and studio up for sale in March, and surrendered his re-entry permit in April. The next year, his wife renounced her US citizenship and became a British citizen.^[315] Chaplin severed the last of his professional ties with the United States in 1955, when he sold the remainder of his stock in United Artists, which had been in financial difficulty since the early 1940s.^[316]

Chaplin remained a controversial figure throughout the 1950s, especially after he was awarded the International Peace Prize by the communist-led World Peace Council, and after his meetings with Zhou Enlai and Nikita Khrushchev.^[317] He began developing his first European film, A King in New York, in 1954.^[318] Casting himself as an exiled king who seeks asylum in the United States, Chaplin included several of his recent experiences in the screenplay. His son, Michael, was cast as a boy whose parents are targeted by the FBI, while Chaplin's character faces accusations of communism.^[319] The political satire parodied HUAC and attacked elements of 1950s culture – including consumerism, plastic surgery, and wide-screen cinema.^[320] In a review, the playwright John Osborne called it Chaplin's "most bitter" and "most openly personal" film.^[321] In a 1957 interview, when asked to clarify his political views, Chaplin stated "As for politics, I am an anarchist. I hate government and rules – and fetters ... People must be free."^[322]

Chaplin founded a new production company, Attica, and used Shepperton Studios for the shooting.^[318] Filming in England proved a difficult experience, as he was used to his own Hollywood studio and familiar crew, and no longer had limitless production time. According to Robinson, this had an effect on the quality of the film.^[323] A King in New York was released in September 1957, and received mixed reviews.^[324] Chaplin banned American journalists from its Paris première and decided not to release the film in the United States. This severely limited its revenue, although it achieved moderate commercial success in Europe.^[325] A King in New York was not shown in America until 1973.^[326][327]

Final works and renewed appreciation

Chaplin with his wife Oona and six of their children in 1961

In the last two decades of his career, Chaplin concentrated on re-editing and scoring his old films for re-release, along with securing their ownership and distribution rights.^[328] In an interview he gave in 1959, the year of his 70th birthday, Chaplin stated that there was still "room for the Little Man in the atomic age".^[329] The first of these re-releases was The Chaplin Revue (1959), which included new versions of A Dog's Life, Shoulder Arms, and The Pilgrim.^[329]

In America, the political atmosphere began to change and attention was once again directed to Chaplin's films instead of his views.^[328] In July 1962, the New York Times published an editorial stating, "We do not believe the Republic would be in danger if yesterday's unforgotten little tramp were allowed to amble down the gangplank of a steamer or plane in an American port".^[330] The same month, Chaplin was invested with the honorary degree of Doctor of Letters by the universities of Oxford and Durham.^[331] In November 1963, the Plaza Theater in New York started a year-long series of Chaplin's films, including Monsieur Verdoux and Limelight, which gained excellent reviews from American critics.^[332] September 1964 saw the release of Chaplin's memoir, My Autobiography, which he had been working on since 1957.^[333] The 500-page book became a worldwide best-seller. It focused on his early years and personal life, and was criticised for lacking information on his film career.^[334]

Shortly after the publication of his memoirs, Chaplin began work on A Countess from Hong Kong (1967), a romantic comedy based on a script he had written for Paulette Goddard in the 1930s.^[335] Set on an ocean liner, it starred Marlon Brando as an American ambassador and Sophia Loren as a stowaway found in his cabin.^[335] The film differed from Chaplin's earlier productions in several aspects. It was his first to use Technicolor and the widescreen format, while he concentrated on directing and appeared on-screen only in a cameo role as a seasick steward.^[336] He also signed a deal with Universal Pictures and appointed his assistant, Jerome Epstein, as the producer.^[337] Chaplin was paid $600,000 director's fee as well as a percentage of the gross receipts.^[338] A Countess from Hong Kong premiered in January 1967, to unfavourable reviews, and was a box-office failure.^[339][340] Chaplin was deeply hurt by the negative reaction to the film, which turned out to be his last.^[339]

Chaplin had a series of minor strokes in the late 1960s, which marked the beginning of a slow decline in his health.^[341] Despite the setbacks, he was soon writing a new film script, The Freak, a story of a winged girl found in South America, which he intended as a starring vehicle for his daughter, Victoria.^[341] His fragile health prevented the project from being realised.^[342] In the early 1970s, Chaplin concentrated on re-releasing his old films, including The Kid and The Circus.^[343] In 1971, he was made a Commander of the National Order of the Legion of Honour at the Cannes Film Festival.^[344] The following year, he was honoured with a special award by the Venice Film Festival.^[345]

Chaplin (right) receiving his Honorary Academy Award from Jack Lemmon in 1972. It was the first time he had been to the United States in twenty years.

In 1972, the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences offered Chaplin an Honorary Award, which Robinson sees as a sign that America "wanted to make amends". Chaplin was initially hesitant about accepting but decided to return to the US for the first time in 20 years.^[344] The visit attracted a large amount of press coverage and, at the Academy Awards gala, he was given a 12-minute standing ovation, the longest in the academy's history.^[346] Visibly emotional, Chaplin accepted his award for "the incalculable effect he has had in making motion pictures the art form of this century".^[347]

Although Chaplin still had plans for future film projects, by the mid-1970s he was very frail.^[348] He experienced several further strokes, which made it difficult for him to communicate, and he had to use a wheelchair.^[349][350] His final projects were compiling a pictorial autobiography, My Life in Pictures (1974) and scoring A Woman of Paris for re-release in 1976.^[351] He also appeared in a documentary about his life, The Gentleman Tramp (1975), directed by Richard Patterson.^[352] In the 1975 New Year Honours, Chaplin was awarded a knighthood by Queen Elizabeth II,^{[351][353][lower-alpha 36]} though he was too weak to kneel and received the honour in his wheelchair.^[355]

Death

Chaplin's grave in Corsier-sur-Vevey, Switzerland

By October 1977, Chaplin's health had declined to the point that he needed constant care.^[356] In the early morning of Christmas Day 1977, Chaplin died at home after having a stroke in his sleep.^[350] He was 88 years old. The funeral, on 27 December, was a small and private Anglican ceremony, according to his wishes.^{[357][lower-alpha 37]} Chaplin was interred in the Corsier-sur-Vevey cemetery.^[356] Among the film industry's tributes, director René Clair wrote, "He was a monument of the cinema, of all countries and all times ... the most beautiful gift the cinema made to us."^[359] Actor Bob Hope declared, "We were lucky to have lived in his time."^[360] Chaplin left more than $100 million to his widow.^[361]

On 1 March 1978, Chaplin's coffin was dug up and stolen from its grave by Roman Wardas and Gantcho Ganev. The body was held for ransom in an attempt to extort money from his widow, Oona Chaplin. The pair were caught in a large police operation in May, and Chaplin's coffin was found buried in a field in the nearby village of Noville. It was re-interred in the Corsier cemetery in a reinforced concrete vault.^[362][363]